Characterization and simulation of uncertain frequency distributions: Effects of distribution choice, variability, uncertainty, and parameter dependence

We use bootstrap simulation to characterize uncertainty in parametric distributions, including Normal, Lognormal, Gamma, Weibull, and Beta, commonly used to represent variability in probabilistic assessments. Bootstrap simulation enables one to estimate sampling distributions for sample statistics, such as distribution parameters, even when analytical solutions are not available. Using a two-dimensional framework for both uncertainty and variability, uncertainties in cumulative distribution functions were simulated. The mathematical properties of uncertain frequency distributions were evaluated in a series of case studies during which the parameters of each type of distribution were varied for sample sizes of 5, 10, and 20. For positively skewed distributions such as Lognormal, Weibull, and Gamma, the range of uncertainty is widest at the upper tail of the distribution. For symmetric unbounded distributions, such as Normal, the uncertainties are widest at both tails of the distribution. For bounded distributions, such as Beta, the uncertainties are typically widest in the central portions of the distribution. Bootstrap simulation enables complex dependencies between sampling distributions to be captured. The effects of uncertainty, variability, and parameter dependencies were studied for several generic functional forms of models, including models in which two-dimensional random variables are added, multiplied, and divided, to show the sensitivity of model results to different assumptions regarding model input distributions, ranges of variability, and ranges of uncertainty and to show the types of errors that may be obtained from mis-specification of parameter dependence. A total of 1,098 case studies were simulated. In some cases, counter-intuitive results were obtained. For example, the point value of the 95th percentile of uncertainty for the 95th percentile of variability of the product of four Gamma or Weibull distributions decreases as the coefficient of variation of each model input increases and, therefore, may not provide a conservative estimate. Failure to properly characterize parameter uncertainties and their dependencies can lead to orders-of-magnitude mis-estimates of both variability and uncertainty. In many cases, the numerical stability of two-dimensional simulation results was found to decrease as the coefficient of variation of the inputs increases. We discuss the strengths and limitations of bootstrap simulation as a method for quantifying uncertainty due to random sampling error.