Within-subject comparisons of maxillary fixed and removable implant prostheses - Patient satisfaction and choice of prosthesis

Dental implants provide patients with restorative options for the edentulous maxilla. Both fixed and removable prostheses can be attached to the edentulous maxilla, but the efficacy of different designs has not been determined. In this two-session within-subject crossover trial we compared maxillary implant retained fixed prostheses with removable implant overdentures opposed by mandibular implant-supported overdentures. Sixteen patients, who had previously received mandibular implants, entered the study and received four to six maxillary implants. After dropouts as a consequence of a lack of osseointegration and general health problems, 13 remained. Of these, five received the removable prosthesis first and eight the fixed prosthesis. After 2 months, the prostheses were exchanged and the second was also worn for 2 months. Psychometric measurements of general satisfaction with the prostheses as well as comfort, ability to speak, stability, esthetics, ease of cleaning and occlusion were obtained once each prosthesis had been worn for 2 months. Chewing ability was assessed for seven types of food. Removable long-bar overdentures received significantly higher ratings of general satisfaction than fixed prostheses (P = 0.003). Patients also rated their ability to speak and ease of cleaning significantly better with the removable overclentures. Nine patients chose to keep the removable pros-thesis and four preferred to keep the fixed prosthesis. The results suggest that maxillary removable overclentures on multiple implants may provide patients with better function than fixed prostheses. Heydecke G, Boudrias P, Awad IVIA, de Albuquerque Jr RF, Lund JP, Feine JS. Within subject comparisons of maxillary fixed and removable implant prostheses: Patient satisfaction and choice of prosthesis.