Real space electron delocalization, resonance, and aromaticity in chemistry

Chemists explaining a molecule's stability and reactivity often refer to the concepts of delocalization, resonance, and aromaticity. Resonance is commonly discussed within valence bond theory as the stabilizing effect of mixing different Lewis structures. Yet, most computational chemists work with delocalized molecular orbitals, which are also usually employed to explain the concept of aromaticity, a ring delocalization in cyclic planar systems which abide certain number rules. However, all three concepts lack a real space definition, that is not reliant on orbitals or specific wave function expansions. Here, we outline a redefinition from first principles: delocalization means that likely electron arrangements are connected via paths of high probability density in the many-electron real space. In this picture, resonance is the consideration of additional electron arrangements, which offer alternative paths. Most notably, the famous 4n + 2 Huckel rule is generalized and derived from nothing but the antisymmetry of fermionic wave functions. The concept of delocalization, resonance and aromaticity are commonly discussed within electronic structure frameworks relying on specific wave function expansions. Here the authors propose a redefinition of these concepts from first-principles by investigating saddle points of the all-electron probability density.