Bare Particulars Laid Bare

被引:3
|
作者
Perovic, Katarina [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Iowa, Dept Philosophy, 270 English Philosophy Bldg, Iowa City, IA 52242 USA
关键词
Bare particulars; Individuation; Constituent ontology; INDIVIDUATION;
D O I
10.1007/s12136-016-0308-x
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
Bare particulars have received a fair amount of bad press. Many find such entities to be obviously incoherent and dismiss them without much consideration. Proponents of bare particulars, on their part, have not done enough to clearly motivate and characterize bare particulars, thus leaving them open to misinterpretations. With this paper, I try to remedy this situation. I put forward a much-needed positive case for bare particulars through the four problems that they can be seen to solve-The Problem of Individuation, The Problem of Change, The Problem of Having a Property, and The Problem of Subtraction. I then distinguish and characterize three possible types of bare particulars-genuinely bare, constitutively bare, and thinly clothed-and consider how each of these cope with some classical and recent objections to bare particulars. I argue that the most troubling objections do not come from familiar quarters, but from examining how well such entities address all four of the ontological problems outlined. I ultimately conclude that the best contenders among the three types of bare particulars are the constitutively bare variety, but argue that, if they are to earn their keep, they must either share or turn over their individuating role to the ordinary particulars that they constitute.
引用
收藏
页码:277 / 295
页数:19
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Bare Particulars Laid Bare
    Katarina Perović
    [J]. Acta Analytica, 2017, 32 : 277 - 295
  • [2] Bare particulars (Answering complaints about "bare particulars")
    Sider, Theodore
    [J]. NOUS, 2006, : 387 - 397
  • [3] BARE PARTICULARS
    ALLAIRE, EB
    [J]. PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES, 1963, 14 (1-2) : 1 - 8
  • [4] No bare particulars
    Bailey, Andrew M.
    [J]. PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES, 2012, 158 (01) : 31 - 41
  • [5] No bare particulars
    Andrew M. Bailey
    [J]. Philosophical Studies, 2012, 158 : 31 - 41
  • [6] LAID BARE
    Celan, Paul
    [J]. STAND, 2013, 12 (01): : 34 - 35
  • [7] Are Bare Particulars Constituents?
    Richard Brian Davis
    [J]. Acta Analytica, 2013, 28 : 395 - 410
  • [8] Are Bare Particulars Constituents?
    Davis, Richard Brian
    [J]. ACTA ANALYTICA-INTERNATIONAL PERIODICAL FOR PHILOSOPHY IN THE ANALYTICAL TRADITION, 2013, 28 (04): : 395 - 410
  • [9] BARE PARTICULARS AND EXEMPLIFICATION
    Pickavance, Timothy
    [J]. AMERICAN PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY, 2014, 51 (02) : 95 - 108
  • [10] Yes: Bare Particulars!
    Niall Connolly
    [J]. Philosophical Studies, 2015, 172 : 1355 - 1370