Poking Holes: Looking for Gaps in LIGO/Virgo's Black Hole Population

Stellar evolution models predict the existence of a gap in the black hole mass spectrum from similar to 55 M-circle dot-120M(circle dot) due to pair-instability supernovae (PISNe). We investigate the possible existence of such an "upper" mass gap in the second gravitational-wave transient catalog (GWTC-2) by hierarchically modeling the astrophysical distribution of black hole masses. We extend the TRUNCATED and POWERLAW+PEAK mass distribution families to allow for an explicit gap in the mass distribution, and apply the extended models to GWTC-2. We find that with the TRUNCATED model there is mild evidence favoring an upper mass gap with log Bayes Factor ln. = 2.79, inferring the lower and upper bounds at 56.12 (+7.54)(-4.38) M-circle dot and 103.74 (+17.01)(-6.32) M-circle dot respectively. When using the POWERLAW+PEAK model, we find no preference for the gap. When imposing tighter priors on the gap bounds centered on the expected PISNe gap bounds, the log Bayes factors in favor of a gap mildly increase. These results are however contingent on the parameter inference for the most massive binary, GW190521, for which follow-up analyses showed the source may be an intermediate mass ratio merger that has component masses straddling the gap. Using the GW190521 posterior samples from the analysis in Nitz & Capano (2021), we find an increase in Bayes factors in favor of the gap. However, the overall conclusions are unchanged: there is no preference for a gap when using the POWERLAW+PEAK model. This work paves the way for constraining the physics of pair-instability and pulsational pair-instability supernovae and high-mass black hole formation.