The hygroscopicity and oxidation level of secondary organic aerosol (SOA) produced in an atmospheric simulation chamber were measured as a function of volatility. The experimental setup combines thermodenuding, isothermal dilution, aerosol mass spectroscopy, and size-resolved cloud condensation nuclei measurements to separate the SOA by volatility and then measure its physical (hygroscopicity via the hygroscopicity parameter, kappa) and chemical (oxidation level via the oxygen-to-carbon ratio, O:C) properties. The technique was applied to SOA from the ozonolysis of alpha-pinene, limonene, and cyclohexene. The O:C and kappa of the alpha-pinene ozonolysis SOA decreased as volatility decreased. The semi-volatile and the low volatility organic compounds produced during limonene ozonolysis have similar O:C and kappa values, but the corresponding extremely low volatility organic compounds have significantly lower oxygen content and hygroscopicity. The average O:C of the cyclohexene ozonolysis SOA increased, but the average kappa decreased as volatility decreased. These results suggest that some organic aerosol (OA) systems have a more complex relationship between hygroscopicity, oxidation level, and volatility than originally thought. The two-dimensional volatility basis set framework can help in integrating these results and providing explanations of the measured hygroscopicity. Use of this technique with different OA systems, both laboratory and ambient, can supply parameters that can be incorporated in atmospheric chemical transport models.