How similar are whiplash and mild traumatic brain injury? A systematic review

被引:13
|
作者
Gil, C. [1 ]
Decq, P. [2 ,3 ,4 ]
机构
[1] Hop Nationaux St Maurice, Dept Rheumatol & Rehabil, 12-14 Rue Val dOsne, F-94410 St Maurice, France
[2] Univ Paris Diderot, Sorbonne Paris Cite, Paris, France
[3] Beaujon Hosp, AP HP, Dept Neurosurg, Clichy, France
[4] Arts & Metiers ParisTech, Georges Charpak Human Biomecan Inst, Paris, France
关键词
Whiplash; Mild traumatic brain injury; Head trauma; TASK-FORCE; WHITE-MATTER; TRUNK SWAY; CONCUSSION; DISORDERS; SYMPTOMS; NECK; CLASSIFICATION; PHYSIOTHERAPY; DISTURBANCES;
D O I
10.1016/j.neuchi.2021.01.016
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Introduction. - Mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) and whiplash are two pathologies which appear in the follow-up of a cranio-cervical trauma. The objective of this study is to review their definitions, to discuss each entity. Methods. - Whiplash and mTBI were defined. Then, a systematic literature review was carried out using the Pubmed database. Relevant studies after 1995 were selected, with 16 articles describing a link between whiplash and mTBI. 8 articles were analyzed after reading their abstracts. Results. - Whiplash and mTBI have many similarities (symptoms, biomechanics, cognitive disorders, presence of diffuse axonal lesions on functional imaging) and some differences (in posture, more vestibular and balance disorders in whiplash). mTBIs result from linear accelerations between 60- 160 g (gravity), studies on whiplash have shown that they can appear from 4.5 g, which could explain biomechanically the frequent concomitant appearance. Cervical joint dysfunction can appear in persistent concussive syndrome, with upper cervical pain, less endurance of the cervical flexor muscles, and an increase in cervical stiffness leading to tension headache. This could explain neck pain in mTBI and headache in whiplash. An explanation to vestibular and cochlear disorders is given, and the two pathologies concomitantly could increase the symptoms. Conclusion. - To our knowledge, no studies define distinct boundaries between these two pathologies, which overlap on many points. An explanation is their concomitant onset, due to the biomechanics of the trauma and anatomical reasons. Larger-scale studies of rigorous scientific quality are needed to answer the question of the difference between whiplash and mTBI. (C) 2021 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:238 / 243
页数:6
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] A systematic review of treatments for mild traumatic brain injury
    Comper, P
    Bisschop, SM
    Carnide, N
    Tricco, A
    [J]. BRAIN INJURY, 2005, 19 (11) : 863 - 880
  • [2] Neuroimaging in paediatric mild traumatic brain injury: a systematic review
    Rausa, Vanessa C.
    Shapiro, Jesse
    Seal, Marc L.
    Davis, Gavin A.
    Anderson, Vicki
    Babl, Franz E.
    Veal, Ryan
    Parkin, Georgia
    Ryan, Nicholas P.
    Takagi, Michael
    [J]. NEUROSCIENCE AND BIOBEHAVIORAL REVIEWS, 2020, 118 : 643 - 653
  • [3] Neuromodulation for Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Rehabilitation: A Systematic Review
    Buhagiar, Francesca
    Fitzgerald, Melinda
    Bell, Jason
    Allanson, Fiona
    Pestell, Carmela
    [J]. FRONTIERS IN HUMAN NEUROSCIENCE, 2020, 14
  • [4] Seizures following mild traumatic brain injury and whiplash: A case report
    Schmidt, H.
    Schaumann-von Stosch Suva, R.
    [J]. EPILEPSIA, 2006, 47 : 51 - 52
  • [5] Diagnosis and Management of Mild Traumatic Brain Injury in Children A Systematic Review
    Lumba-Brown, Angela
    Yeates, Keith Owen
    Sarmiento, Kelly
    Breiding, Matthew J.
    Haegerich, Tamara M.
    Gioia, Gerard A.
    Turner, Michael
    Benzel, Edward C.
    Suskauer, Stacy J.
    Giza, Christopher C.
    Joseph, Madeline
    Broomand, Catherine
    Weissman, Barbara
    Gordon, Wayne
    Wright, David W.
    Moser, Rosemarie Scolaro
    McAvoy, Karen
    Ewing-Cobbs, Linda
    Duhaime, Ann-Christine
    Putukian, Margot
    Holshouser, Barbara
    Paulk, David
    Wade, Shari L.
    Herring, Stanley A.
    Halstead, Mark
    Keenan, Heather T.
    Choe, Meeryo
    Christian, Cindy W.
    Guskiewicz, Kevin
    Raksin, P. B.
    Gregory, Andrew
    Mucha, Anne
    Taylor, H. Gerry
    Callahan, James M.
    DeWitt, John
    Collins, Michael W.
    Kirkwood, Michael W.
    Ragheb, John
    Ellenbogen, Richard G.
    Spinks, T. J.
    Ganiats, Theodore G.
    Sabelhaus, Linda J.
    Altenhofen, Katrina
    Hoffman, Rosanne
    Getchius, Tom
    Gronseth, Gary
    Donnell, Zoe
    O'Connor, Robert E.
    Timmons, Shelly D.
    [J]. JAMA PEDIATRICS, 2018, 172 (11)
  • [6] Systematic review of depression in mild traumatic brain injury: Study protocol
    Lepage C.
    Yuan T.
    Leon S.
    Marshall S.
    Labelle P.
    Ferland M.
    [J]. Systematic Reviews, 5 (1)
  • [7] Systematic Review of Multivariable Prognostic Models for Mild Traumatic Brain Injury
    Silverberg, Noah D.
    Gardner, Andrew J.
    Brubacher, Jeffrey R.
    Panenka, William J.
    Li, Jun Jian
    Iverson, Grant L.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF NEUROTRAUMA, 2015, 32 (08) : 517 - 526
  • [8] Fluid Biomarkers of Pediatric Mild Traumatic Brain Injury: A Systematic Review
    Mannix, Rebekah
    Levy, Rachel
    Zemek, Roger
    Yeates, Keith Owen
    Arbogast, Kristy
    Meehan, William P.
    Leddy, John
    Master, Christina
    Mayer, Andrew R.
    Howell, David R.
    Meier, Timothy B.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF NEUROTRAUMA, 2020, 37 (19) : 2029 - 2044
  • [9] Magnetoencephalography abnormalities in adult mild traumatic brain injury: A systematic review
    Allen, Christopher M.
    Halsey, Lloyd
    Topcu, Gogem
    Rier, Lukas
    Gascoyne, Lauren E.
    Scadding, John W.
    Furlong, Paul L.
    Dunkley, Benjamin T.
    das Nair, Roshan
    Brookes, Matthew J.
    Evangelou, Nikos
    [J]. NEUROIMAGE-CLINICAL, 2021, 31
  • [10] Blood biomarkers in paediatric mild traumatic brain injury: a systematic review
    Lugones, Micaela
    Parkin, Georgia
    Bjelosevic, Stefan
    Takagi, Michael
    Clarke, Cathriona
    Anderson, Vicki
    Ignjatovic, Vera
    [J]. NEUROSCIENCE AND BIOBEHAVIORAL REVIEWS, 2018, 87 : 206 - 217