Substructure in the cell survival response at low radiation dose: Effect of different subpopulations

In order to obtain more accurate measurements of cell survival after low doses of radiation, we have used the cell sorter assay, in which a cell sorter is used to accurately count out the number of cells plated for colony formation. This method, combined with data averaging, permits measurements of survival with superior precision, which have revealed that there is substructure in the radiation response of asynchronously dividing Chinese hamster cells. The substructure, observed at doses of a few Gy, has features of a 2-component response, consistent with the presence of subpopulations of cells of different cell-cycle-related radiosensitivity. The absence of any substructure in the radiation response of homogeneous (tightly synchronized) cell populations lends strong support to this subpopulation explanation of the substructure. This assay has also been used on a variety of human tumour cell lines, most of which exhibited substructure similar to that of Chinese hamster cells. This paper outlines the application of the cell sorter assay to three different problems: (i) radiosensitizer mechanisms-etanidazole and RB 6145 are shown to enhance primarily the beta term and alpha term, respectively, of tumour cell kill, indicating that sensitizer efficacy may be tumour-specific and predictable from tumour response parameters; (ii) accurate measurement of Relative Biological Effectiveness (RBE) in a modulated clinical proton beam shows that the RBE is both dose- and depth- dependent; and (iii) measurements at lower doses clearly demonstrate a second order of substructure, termed the hypersensitive response, at doses < 1 Gy.