Is Ice Nucleation by Organic Crystals Nonclassical? An Assessment of the Monolayer Hypothesis of Ice Nucleation

Potent ice nucleating organic crystals display an increase in nucleation efficiency with pressure and memory effect after pressurization that set them apart from inorganic nucleants. These characteristics were proposed to arise from an ordered water monolayer at the organic-water interface. It was interpreted that ordering of the monolayer is the limiting step for ice nucleation on organic crystals, rendering their mechanism of nucleation nonclassical. Despite the importance of organics in atmospheric ice nucleation, that explanation has never been investigated. Here we elucidate the structure of interfacial water and its role in ice nucleation at ambient pressure on phloroglucinol dihydrate, the paradigmatic example of outstanding ice nucleating organic crystal, using molecular simulations. The simulations confirm the existence of an interfacial monolayer that orders on cooling and becomes fully ordered upon ice formation. The monolayer does not resemble any ice face but seamlessly connects the distinct hydrogen-bonding orders of ice and the organic surface. Although large ordered patches develop in the monolayer before ice nucleates, we find that the critical step is the formation of the ice crystallite, indicating that the mechanism is classical. We predict that the fully ordered, crystalline monolayer nucleates ice above -2 degrees C and could be responsible for the exceptional ice nucleation by the organic crystal at high pressures. The lifetime of the fully ordered monolayer around 0 degrees C, however, is too short to account for the memory effect reported in the experiments. The latter could arise from an increase in the melting temperature of ice confined by strongly ice-binding surfaces.