N-Heterocyclic Carbenes-CuI Complexes as Catalysts: A Theoretical Insight

The electronic structures of N-heterocyclic carbenes (NHC) imidazolinylidene, thiazolinylidene, imidazolylidene, thiazolylidene, and 1,2,4-triazolylidene and their complexes with cuprous halides (CuX, X = Cl, Br, I) were investigated theoretically at the B3LYP/def2-SVP level. In contrast to other NHCs, imidazolylidene and 1,2,4-triazolylidene do not dimerize owing to the negligible coefficient of the vacant p-orbital at the carbene centre in their respective LUMOs. This is further supported by their greater thermodynamic and kinetic stabilities revealed by greater activation free energies and smaller standard free energies for their dimerization. Second-order perturbation interactions in the natural bond orbital (NBO) analysis of the NHCs indicate that six pi electrons are delocalized in imidazolylidene, thiazolylidene, and 1,2,4-triazolylidene, conferring aromatic character and thereby enhancing their thermodynamic stability. NBO analysis reveals the existence of effective back bonding from a d orbital of Cu to the NHC, increasing the Wiberg bond index of the C-Cu bond to similar to 1.5. Owing to the large electronic chemical potential (m) and high nucleophilicity indices, NHCs are able to transfer their electron density effectively to the cuprous halides having low m values and high electrophilicity indices to yield stable NHC-Cu-I complexes. Large values of the Fukui function f(r) at the carbene centre of the NHCs and Cu atom of the NHC-Cu-I complexes indicate their softness. Imidazolylidene was found to be the softest, rationalizing wide use of this class of NHCs as ligands. The coordination of the NHCs to cuprous halides is either barrierless or has a very low activation free energy barrier. In the A(3) reaction wherein NHC-Cu(I) complexes are used as catalyst, the reaction of NHC-CuI with phenylacetylene changes the latter into acetylide accompanied by raising the energy level of its HOMO considerably compared with the level of the uncomplexed alkyne, making its reaction with benzaldehyde barrierless.