A comparison between the patella and the calcaneus using ultrasound velocity and attenuation as predictors of bone mineral density

The bone mineral density (BMD), ultrasound velocity (UV) and attenuation were examined in sixteen matched sets of human patellae and calcanei. For the sixteen calcanei, BMD was strongly correlated with all ultrasound parameters. Calcaneal UV appeared to be inferior to attenuation in the ability to predict BMD. For the sixteen patellae, the average UV was found to be greater in the superior/inferior direction than in the anterior/posterior and medial/lateral directions. It was found that patella BMD was significantly correlated with each of three directional ultrasound velocities. The relationship between BMD and ultrasound attenuation parameters was not significant in the patella. A comparative study of the two different bone sets demonstrated that the BMDs of the patella and calcaneus were significantly correlated with each other. Ultrasound velocity of calcaneus, measured in the medial/lateral direction, was not significantly associated with any of three directional ultrasound velocities in the patella. Similarly, ultrasound attenuation parameters of calcaneus were not significantly correlated with those of patella. The present study also demonstrated evidence that when predicting BMDs at their respective sites using ultrasound, the calcaneus appeared to be superior to the patella.