Direct comparison of cerebrovascular effects of norepinephrine and dopamine in head-injured patients

Objective: To directly compare the cerebrovascular effects of norepinephrine and dopamine in patients with acute traumatic brain injury. Design. Prospective randomized crossover trial. Setting. Neurosciences critical care unit of a university hospital. Patients: Ten acutely head-injured patients requiring vasoactive drugs to maintain a cerebral perfusion pressure of 65 mm Hg. Interventions: Patients were randomized to start the protocol with either norepinephrine or dopamine. Using an infusion of the allocated drug, cerebral perfusion pressure was adjusted to 65 mm Hg. After 20 mins of data collection, cerebral perfusion pressure was increased to 75 mm Hg by increasing the infusion rate of the vasoactive agent. After 20 mins of data collection, cerebral perfusion pressure was increased to 85 mm Hg and again data were collected for 20 mins. Subsequently, the infusion rate of the vasoactive drug was reduced until a cerebral perfusion pressure of 65 mm Hg was reached and the drug was exchanged against the other agent. The protocol was then repeated. Measurements and Main Results. Mean arterial pressure and intracranial pressure were monitored and cerebral blood flow was estimated with transcranial Doppler. Norepinephrine led to predictable and significant increases in flow velocity for each step increase in cerebral perfusion pressure (57.5 +/- 19.9 cm(.)sec(-1), 61.3 +/- 22.3 cm(.)sec(-1), and 68.4 +/- 24.8 cm-sec(-1) at 65, 75, and 85 mm Hg, respectively; p < .05 for all three comparisons), but changes with dopamine were variable and inconsistent. There were no differences between absolute values of flow velocity or intracranial pressure between the two drugs at any cerebral perfusion pressure level. Conclusions. Norepinephrine may be more predictable and efficient to augment cerebral perfusion in patients with traumatic brain injury.