Sequential protocols with thymoglobuline and delayed introduction of calcineurin: effects on renal function in renal transplant recipients with non immunological risk and low risk of delayed Graft function

Induction therapy with thymoglobuline significantly decreases the risk of acute rejection, particularly in high immunological risk patients, in combined transplantations and in pediatric renal transplantation. After the introduction of cyclosporin in the 1980's and the recognition of its potential nephrotoxicity, induction therapy with delayed introduction of cyclosporin (sequential protocols) have became very popular in many transplant centers and are now used even in low-immunological risk patients. The aim of the present study was to assess the recovery of renal function in low-immunological risk patients receiving a sequential protocol versus those receiving a calcineurin inhibitor at day 1. Among patients receiving their first transplant in our center between January 1999 and June 2000, we selected 72 recipients with no immunological risk and no risk of delayed graft function (DGF). 35 patients (group 1) have received a sequential protocol whereas 37 patients (group 11) have received a calcineurin inhibitor (Neoral(R) or prograf(R)) at day 1. We analysed creatinine reduction ratio, 24-hour creatinine excretion on post-transplant day 2, and serum creatinine and creatinine clearance at day 15, 30, 45, 60 and 90 post-transplant. There was no difference between groups concerning demographic, immunological or surgical parameters. The percentage of patients with immediate graft function was similar between the two groups (10 versus 9). The number of patients requiring dialysis in the first post-transplant week was also similar (8/35 versus 6/37). The day serum creatinine reached 200 mumol/l was 15 11 versus 14 12 in groups I and 11 respectively Serum creatinine and creatinine clearance were similar at all time intervals. CMV disease was significantly higher in the group 1(42% versus 18.5%; p < 0.005). Our data suggest that in patients with low immunological risk and low-risk of DGF, introduction of calcineurin inhibitors as early as the post-transplant day 1 is not deleterious for renal function recovery. These data should be confirmed by a prospective randomised trial.