Frequent chloroplast capture among Isodon (Lamiaceae) species in Japan revealed by phylogenies based on variation in chloroplast and nuclear DNA

A recent phylogenetic study based only on chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) variation revealed that populations of an Isodon species are frequently embedded paraphyletically among other Isodon species. This phylogenetic discrepancy between species taxonomy and molecular phylogeny was considered to have resulted from chloroplast DNA captures and/or incomplete lineage sorting. To elucidate which of these factors was mainly responsible for the observed phylogenetic pattern, we performed phylogenetic analyses of multiple populations of Isodon species in Japan using cpDNA variation, three single-copy nuclear genes, and double-digest restriction-site-associated DNA sequencing (ddRAD-seq). Although a species often shared chlorotypes with other species, our phylogenetical analyses based on variation in the three single-copy nuclear genes and the ddRAD-seq data showed that most populations belonging to the same species were monophyletic at the species level, suggesting that chloroplast capture may have frequently occurred between Isodon species. Some populations of an intraspecific taxon were embedded paraphyletically within the species, regardless of the large amount of phylogenetic information in nuclear DNA; this incongruity may have resulted from incomplete lineage sorting.