One ring to rule them all? Locating discourse in Aotearoa New Zealand early childhood education curriculum

Early childhood scholars in New Zealand have long lamented a rising dominance of neoliberalism. Correspondingly they suggest that there has been a lessening of socialist ideals and principles of Te Ao Maori after years of a right-wing government. With the 'refresh' of New Zealand's national early childhood curriculum, Te Whariki under the Fifth National Government we sought to investigate the location of these discourses in Te Whariki. Borrowing from Tolkien this paper draws on the metaphor of a ruling, in this case neoliberal, discourse as 'one ring to rule them all'. We investigate the governmentality of the Fifth National Government through their Four Year Plan 2016-2020 and its permeation of the revised curriculum. Seeking to better understand the location and dominance of neoliberalism within the updated Te Whariki, the paper analyses both the 1996 curriculum and the 2017 revision for socialist, neoliberal and Te Ao Maori discourses, and their status within the document. A post-structuralist conceptual framework is employed for this study, bringing to bear Michel Foucault and Julia Kristeva in conversation. Analysis across both Te Whariki and the Four Year Plan found that while neoliberalism was certainly a pervasive discourse, it was, in fact, accompanied by discourses of socialism, neoliberalism and Te Ao Maori. The paper concludes by suggesting that, while neoliberalism may appear to dominate texts, there are complex interanimations between a number of discourses. This multitude potentially ameliorates any one discourse's domination or, conversely, compromises others. With these findings come important implications concerning the pervasive discourse of neoliberalism and its shaping potential. However, there are also concerns for a new form of colonisation within early childhood curriculum and policy reform.