What happens when we read a mathematical text? Reactivation or delimitation?

被引:0
|
作者
Vinciguerra, Lucien [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Lille, UMR Savoirs Textes Langage 8163, CNRS, Lille, France
来源
关键词
history of mathematics; Husserl; Peletier du Man Jacques; Descartes; Bachelard; Quine; Davidson; mathematical sign;
D O I
10.4000/methodos.7065
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
Historians of mathematics have often noticed a singularity of their discipline: unlike physics, the history of mathematics does not proceed essentially by conjectures and refutations, but by a succession of reinterpretations of the past in order to include it into the actual state of knowledge. This operation involves an act of reading. Taking as its starting point Husserl's theses in The Origin of Geometry on the role of writing in the historicity of mathematics, the article aims to analyze the conditions of possibility of this reading, related to the nature of the mathematical text : this reading involves three delimitations performed by the reader's eye: between true and false, between writing and image, between what is mathematical and what does not. The article illustrates this thesis by examining the status of the equation in the cartesian's book of Geometry. It shows the links between the latter and the ideas that the philosopher develops on reading and on the nature of the sign. On this basis, it is possible to understand how Descartes could read a mathematical text, how this partly explains some points in his Geometry, but also how other readings of this Geometry can include it into the mathematics of later centuries.
引用
收藏
页数:20
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] WHAT HAPPENS WHEN WE READ A POEM
    SILKEY, S
    PURVES, AC
    [J]. JOURNAL OF AESTHETIC EDUCATION, 1973, 7 (03): : 63 - 72
  • [2] What Happens When I Read Conrad?
    Miller, J. Hillis
    [J]. CONRADIANA, 2016, 48 (2-3) : 279 - 285
  • [3] WHAT WE READ WHEN WE READ IN TRANSLATION
    Lunkova, Larisa Nikholaevna
    [J]. RUSSIAN LINGUISTIC BULLETIN, 2015, (03) : 39 - +
  • [4] THE NAIVE AND THE SENTIMENTAL NOVELIST Understanding what happens when we write and read novels
    Gorra, Michael
    [J]. TLS-THE TIMES LITERARY SUPPLEMENT, 2011, (5642): : 10 - 11
  • [5] What Happens When We Pray?
    Wakefield, Andrew H.
    [J]. REVIEW & EXPOSITOR, 2007, 104 (04) : 787 - 809
  • [6] WHAT WE LOOK AT WHEN WE READ
    MEHLER, J
    BEVER, TG
    CAREY, P
    [J]. PERCEPTION & PSYCHOPHYSICS, 1967, 2 (05): : 213 - 218
  • [7] WHAT WE SEE WHEN WE READ
    Kareem, Sarah Tindal
    [J]. AMERICAN BOOK REVIEW, 2017, 38 (05) : 12 - 13
  • [8] What we see when we read
    Cordon Garcia, Jose Antonio
    [J]. ALABE-REVISTA DE INVESTIGACION SOBRE LECTURA Y ESCRITURA, 2016, (13):
  • [9] What happens when we become obsolete?
    Le Page, Michael
    [J]. NEW SCIENTIST, 2011, 211 (2822) : 40 - 41
  • [10] Natalizumab: What Happens When We Stop It?
    Kelly, Siobhan
    Duggan, Marguerite
    Kinsella, Katie
    McGuigan, Christopher
    Tubridy, Niall
    Hutchinson, Michael
    [J]. NEUROLOGY, 2011, 76 (09) : A68 - A69