Health disparities between binary and non binary trans people: A community-driven survey

被引:62
|
作者
Burgwal, Aisa [1 ]
Gvianishvili, Natia [2 ]
Hard, Vierge [3 ]
Kata, Julia [4 ]
Garcia Nieto, Isidro [5 ]
Orre, Cal [3 ]
Smiley, Adam [6 ]
Vidic, Jelena [7 ]
Motmans, Joz [1 ]
机构
[1] Ghent Univ Hosp, Ctr Sexol & Gender, B-9000 Ghent, Belgium
[2] WISG, Tbilisi, Georgia
[3] Riksforbundet Homosexuellas Bisexuellas Transpers, Stockholm, Sweden
[4] Trans Fuzja, Warsaw, Poland
[5] Daniela Fdn, Madrid, Spain
[6] TGEU, Berlin, Germany
[7] Gayten LGBT, Belgrade, Serbia
来源
关键词
Gender identity; genderqueer; health care; nonbinary; quantitative research; sociodemographic background; transgender; QUALITY-OF-LIFE; MENTAL-HEALTH; TRANSGENDER; GENDER; SEX; METAANALYSIS; STRESS; GAY;
D O I
10.1080/15532739.2019.1629370
中图分类号
B849 [应用心理学];
学科分类号
040203 ;
摘要
Background: Genderqueer and nonbinary () people have remained largely invisible in health research. Previous research shows worse outcomes on health indicators for trans people when compared with cisgender controls, but the differences between binary trans and GQNB individuals are inconclusive. Aims: To compare overall health and well-being of GQNB people with controls of trans men and trans women, taking into account the impact of the additive effect of their socio-economic position, as well as their current need for gender affirming medical interventions. Methods: A community-driven survey was conducted in 2016 in five countries (Georgia, Poland, Serbia, Spain, and Sweden). Self-reported health and general well-being were analysed for differences between binary trans and GQNB respondents. The effects of multiple control variables (age, economic situation, educational level, belonging to an ethnic, religious, sexual or ability minority group, sex assigned at birth) as well as the current need for gender affirming medical interventions were controlled for. Results: The sample consisted of 853 respondents aged 16 and older, with 254 trans women (29.8%), 369 trans men (43.2%), and 230 GQNB people (26%). GQNB respondents showed significantly worse self-reported health and worse general well-being in comparison to binary trans respondents. Additional negative impacts of having a lower educational level, having more economic stress, and belonging to a disability minority group were found. Being in need of gender affirming medical interventions contributed significantly to worse self-reported health, whereas being younger contributed to worse general well-being. Discussion: In understanding health disparities between binary trans and GQNB people, it is necessary to take into account the additive effect of multiple socio-economic positions, and the current need for gender affirming medical interventions. The high proportion of GQNB respondents who report worse health outcomes highlights the need for policy makers and health-care providers in creating nonbinary-inclusive environments.
引用
收藏
页码:218 / 229
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Community-Driven Approaches for Reducing Health Disparities in Cancer
    Partridge, Edward
    Fouad, Mona
    [J]. JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2010, 303 (11): : 1090 - 1091
  • [2] Community-Driven Research Agenda to Reduce Health Disparities
    McElfish, Pearl A.
    Kohler, Peter
    Smith, Chris
    Warmack, Scott
    Buron, Bill
    Hudson, Jonell
    Bridges, Melissa
    Purvis, Rachel
    Rubon-Chutaro, Jellesen
    [J]. CTS-CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL SCIENCE, 2015, 8 (06): : 690 - 695
  • [3] The community action model: A community-driven model designed to address disparities in health
    Lavery, SH
    Smith, ML
    Esparza, AA
    Hrushow, A
    Moore, M
    Reed, DF
    [J]. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, 2005, 95 (04) : 611 - 616
  • [4] Health and well-being of trans and non-binary participants in a community-based survey of gay, bisexual, and queer men, and non-binary and Two-Spirit people across Canada
    Rutherford, Leo
    Stark, Aeron
    Ablona, Aidan
    Klassen, Benjamin J.
    Higgins, Robert
    Jacobsen, Hanna
    Draenos, Christopher J.
    Card, Kiffer G.
    Lachowsky, Nathan J.
    [J]. PLOS ONE, 2021, 16 (02):
  • [5] HIV and trans and non-binary people in the UK
    Jaspal, Rusi
    Nambiar, Kate Zoe
    Delpech, Valerie
    Tariq, Shema
    [J]. SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED INFECTIONS, 2018, 94 (05) : 318 - 319
  • [6] A Community-Driven Probability Survey of Disadvantaged Populations in Chicago: Sinai Community Health Survey 2.0
    Hirschtick, Jana L.
    Hughes, Michelle M.
    Farrar, Isabel
    Gutierrez-Kapheim, Melissa
    Owens, Linda
    Johnson, Timothy P.
    Benjamins, Maureen R.
    [J]. PROGRESS IN COMMUNITY HEALTH PARTNERSHIPS-RESEARCH EDUCATION AND ACTION, 2020, 14 (03) : 347 - 357
  • [7] Community-Driven Approach for Youth Health Survey Administration and Data Utilization
    Kattari, Leonardo
    Cikara, Lauren
    Ma, Ming
    Brooks-Russell, Ashley
    [J]. HEALTH PROMOTION PRACTICE, 2021, 22 (02) : 167 - 169
  • [8] Experiences of menopause among non-binary and trans people
    Toze, Michael
    Westwood, Sue
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF TRANSGENDER HEALTH, 2024,
  • [9] Abuse in Chilean Trans and Non-Binary Health Care: Results from a Nationwide Survey
    Rosello-Penaloza, Miguel
    Julio, Lukas
    Alvarez-Aguado, Izaskun
    Farhang, Maryam
    [J]. SOCIAL SCIENCES-BASEL, 2024, 13 (04):
  • [10] Building International Indigenous People’s Partnerships for Community-Driven Health Initiatives
    Tanya R. Wahbe
    Eduardo M. Jovel
    David R. Silva García
    Vicente E. Pilco Llagcha
    N. Rose Point
    [J]. EcoHealth, 2007, 4 : 472 - 488