A proposed framework for establishing and evaluating hypotheses about the behaviour of extinct organisms

Reconstructing the possible behaviours of long extinct species, and especially those with no close living relatives, are naturally fraught with difficulty: data are often limited and hard to interpret. However, the field of palaeoethology has not been helped by a poor understanding of the range and plasticity of the behaviour of extant organisms, coupled with a tendency to generalize and over-interpret the limited information available. Here we attempt to construct a framework for the establishment of viable hypotheses about the behaviour of extinct organisms and the generation of support for, or testing of, these hypotheses. We advocate that it is preferable to under-interpret available data, than to suggest problematic hypotheses that may become accepted as correct.