Marginality, ethnicity and penality: a response to Loic Wacquant

This article responds to Loic Wacquant's elaboration of his overarching theoretical framework in his stimulating article 'Marginality, Ethnicity and Penality in the Neo-liberal City: An Analytic Cartography'. I raise some issues that he might reflect on in his rejoinder to the comments on his essay. These include: (1) the need for greater specification and clarification of explanatory and conceptual variables in the elaboration of his theoretical framework, especially theoretical mechanisms and two key concepts, 'precariat' and 'neo-liberal policy'; and (2) addressing a major study offering empirically based arguments that indirectly challenge assertions in his theoretical framework.