Use of layered double hydroxides (LDHs) in the environmental field is gaining popularity due to their potential to sorb toxic anions, attributed to their large surface area, high anion exchange capacity, and good thermal stability. In this study, four different LDHs (i.e., Cu-Al-, Mg-Al-, Mg-Fe-, and Zn-Al-LDH) were synthesized to select one or more efficient sorbents, capable of removing arsenite [As(III)] from contaminated waters. In particular, we studied the following: (1) X-ray diffraction patterns and specific surface area of the synthesized LDHs; (2) sorption isotherms of As(III) at pH 7.0; and (3) sorption of As(III) on LDHs, in the presence of inorganic anions [carbonate (CO3), chloride (Cl), fluoride (F), phosphate (PO4), sulfate (SO4)] commonly present in aquatic environments. The poorly crystalline LDHs (i.e., Cu-Al-LDH and Mg-Fe-LDH) sorbed greater amounts of As(III) than the well-crystalline LDHs (i.e, Mg-Al-LDH and Zn-Al-LDH). The efficiency of the competing anions at inhibiting As(III) sorption by the LDHs was Cl <= F < SO4 << CO3 << PO4, regardless of initial ligand/As(III) molar ratios (R) or LDH. Although Cu-Al-LDH sorbed lower amounts of As(III) than the Mg-Fe-LDH, it showed, surprisingly, a higher affinity for As(III). This surprising behavior puts this LDH in the forefront as a potential sorbent for the treatment of arsenic-contaminated waters.