Influence of release size on establishment and impact of a root weevil for the biocontrol of houndstongue (Cynoglossum officinale)

The root-boring weevil, Mogulones cruciger, was introduced into Canada to control the weed, houndstongue (Cynoglossum officinale). To optimise its use as a biocontrol agent, a 2-year study was performed in British Columbia, Canada to test if the number of M. cruciger released at sites predicted subsequent declines in weed populations. No, 100, 200, 300 or 400 weevils were released in 1999 at field sites (five replicates) corresponding to discrete populations of houndstongue separated by distances of 0.3-3 km. The sites were subsequently monitored for weevil establishment, population change, and host attack, and houndstongue population change. By 2001, M. cruciger had established at all 20 release sites and was present in low numbers in three of five control sites. The year following release, release size was positively correlated with number of adult weevils collected, their damage to host plants, and with subsequent numbers of larvae per plant. In contrast, houndstongue populations were reduced at the same rate and amount, regardless of the experimental release size, within 2 years of release. Significant release treatmenttime interactions indicated that factors other than M. cruciger contributed to houndstongue reductions (e.g. drought). However, overall the addition of weevils accelerated the reductions relative to sites with no weevils added. Our study demonstrated that the lowest number within a range of release sizes typically used in weed biocontrol programmes (i.e. 100) was as effective as 200-400 weevils in achieving a consistent amount and rate of houndstongue reduction, and thus, could be implemented to optimise weevil use and achieve predictable biocontrol.