Impact of margin for target volume in low-dose involved field radiotherapy after induction chemotherapy for intracranial germinoma

Purpose: We previously published a report stating that germinomas with elevated serum beta human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG-beta) had a poor relapse rate, but these findings have not been supported by a multi-institutional trial. The margin for initial gross tumor volume (GTV) before surgery and chemotherapy of the same materials was investigated by retrospective review. Methods and Material: The 27 patients reported on in the previous paper were analyzed. The two-dimensional margin from the initial GTV to 90% of the prescribed dose of 24 Gy was 2.0 cm for a solitary lesion in the protocol. This margin was measured retrospectively without knowledge of the serum HCG-beta level. The whole ventricle field was used for patients with multifocal disease and whole central nervous system field was used for disseminated disease, respectively. Results: Six relapses were seen in 18 patients with solitary tumors, and were treated with the minimum margin of 1.5 cm or less to the initial GTV. Five of the 6 had initially elevated serum HCG-beta at the median of 7.4 mIU/mL, ranging from 0.7-233 mIU/mL. No relapses were seen in the 9 patients who were treated with whole ventricle or whole central nervous system field. Conclusions: An inadequate margin and elevated serum HCG-beta were equally determined to be candidates that caused the poor local control. The whole ventricle is recommended as the smallest target volume for germinoma with or without elevated HCG-beta after induction chemotherapy. (C) 2004 Elsevier Inc.