Peirce on the justification of abduction

被引:7
|
作者
Bellucci, Francesco [1 ]
Pietarinen, Ahti-Veikko [2 ,3 ]
机构
[1] Univ Bologna, Bologna, Italy
[2] Tallinn Univ Technol, Tallinn, Estonia
[3] Res Univ Higher Sch Econ, Moscow, Russia
关键词
Peirce; Abduction; Hypothetic-deductive method; Induction; Logic; Classification of arguments; Scientific inquiry;
D O I
10.1016/j.shpsa.2020.04.003
中图分类号
N09 [自然科学史]; B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ; 010108 ; 060207 ; 060305 ; 0712 ;
摘要
What sort of justification can be claimed for abduction? In this paper we reconstruct Peirce's answer to this question. We show that in his early works on the logic of science Peirce provided an abductive justification of abduction, and that in his mature writings the early solution is enriched by a reference to the place abduction has in a typical scientific inquiry. Since abduction is the first stage of inquiry by which a hypothesis is suggested and which then has to be subjected to inductive testing, the fundamental abduction (ur-abduction) that justifies abduction has also to be subjected to a verification by means of a fundamental induction (ur-induction), namely that the abduction that abduction is valid is verified by an appeal to the history of science.
引用
收藏
页码:12 / 19
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Eco and Peirce on Abduction
    Bellucci, Francesco
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PRAGMATISM AND AMERICAN PHILOSOPHY, 2018, 10 (01):
  • [2] THE ECONOMY OF PEIRCE ABDUCTION
    BROWN, WM
    TRANSACTIONS OF THE CHARLES S PEIRCE SOCIETY, 1983, 19 (04): : 397 - 411
  • [3] PEIRCE NOTION OF ABDUCTION
    FRANKFURT, HG
    JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 1958, 55 (14): : 593 - 597
  • [4] Borges and Peirce, on abduction and maps
    Almeida, I
    SEMIOTICA, 2002, 140 (1-4) : 13 - 31
  • [5] PEIRCE - A TOOL FOR EXPERIMENTING WITH ABDUCTION
    PUNCH, WF
    TANNER, MC
    JOSEPHSON, JR
    SMITH, JW
    IEEE EXPERT-INTELLIGENT SYSTEMS & THEIR APPLICATIONS, 1990, 5 (05): : 34 - 44
  • [6] SUBCONSCIOUSNESS AND ABDUCTION, FREUD AND PEIRCE
    BALAT, M
    DEGRES-REVUE DE SYNTHESE A ORIENTATION SEMIOLOGIQUE, 1988, (54-55): : K1 - K21
  • [7] Peirce on abduction and rational control
    Brogaard, BO
    TRANSACTIONS OF THE CHARLES S PEIRCE SOCIETY, 1999, 35 (01): : 129 - 155
  • [8] THE EVOLUTION OF PEIRCE CONCEPT OF ABDUCTION
    ANDERSON, DR
    TRANSACTIONS OF THE CHARLES S PEIRCE SOCIETY, 1986, 22 (02): : 145 - 164
  • [9] ABDUCTION IN INDUCTION IN PEIRCE: EVOLUTION AND CRITERIA
    Nino, Douglas
    DESIGNIS, 2012, 20 : 153 - +
  • [10] Problems with Peirce's concept of abduction
    Hoffmann M.
    Foundations of Science, 1999, 4 (3) : 271 - 305