In the prologue to Marguerite de Navarre'sHeptameron, Hircan pronounces, 'In the game, we are all equal.' This declaration of equality among the group of would-be storytellers is a surprising one, but its meaning - and Marguerite's point - is unclear. Is this a nascent feminist statement, or is it a theological one about the status of human beings before their God? In this paper, I will explore how theHeptameron's frame story, along with the content of the tales themselves, both reveal Marguerite's approach to the question of equality between the sexes. Reading the Heptameron through the biblical and exegetical lens of the book of Genesis suggests that a truce in the battle of the sexes may be more a question of accepting hard realities rather than hoping that men and women can overcome divisions that go back to the Fall.