We Like Copies, Just Don't Let the Others Fool You: The Paradox of The Pirate Bay

The Facebook page of the anti-copyright The Pirate Bay (TPB) explains much about the group in few words. We like copies, it explains, just don't let the others fool you. The paradoxical phrase reveals the contradictions of TPB. Their use of copies deliberately chaffs with their opponents who equate piracy with theft of intellectual property. Pirates copy digital bits; they do not steal intellectual property. Championing copying is problematic for a group at the center of the Piracy Movement. The warning that others [might] fool you acknowledges the tensions brought about by celebrating copying while depending on their privileged voice. This article addresses these contradictions by describing TPB as an assemblage defined by conflicting forces of centripetal pull and centrifugal push. Understanding the contradictions of TPB offers greater insights into the challenges faced by other Hacktivism groups as they struggle for political change and legitimacy.