Foreshadowing Spinoza Johannes Clauberg on God and Miracles

This paper examines two interpretations of a passage in Descartes's text. Johannes Clauberg and Benedict Spinoza comment on the same paragraph in the Principles of Philosophy (1646). Descartes, in the paragraph, argues that the same amount of motion remains in the universe because of God's immutable essence and operation. On the one hand, Clauberg embraces Descartes's physics in general but modifies it to suit the theological tradition of the Reformed church, which held the official confession for where his professional career mattered. Spinoza, on the other hand, gets rid of all traces of the biblical religion from Descartes's physics. While particular theological (or antitheological) positions of these thinkers dictate their interpretations of Descartes's text, their solutions are surprisingly similar.