A formalization of argumentation schemes for legal case-based reasoning in ASPIC

被引：51
|
作者：
Prakken, Henry [1 ,2 ]
Wyner, Adam [3 ]
Bench-Capon, Trevor [4 ]
Atkinson, Katie [4 ]
机构：
[1] Univ Groningen, Fac Law, NL-3584 CC Utrecht, Netherlands
[2] Univ Utrecht, Dept Informat & Comp Sci, Buys Ballot Lab, Off 523, NL-3584 CC Utrecht, Netherlands
[3] Univ Aberdeen, Dept Comp Sci, Aberdeen AB24 3UE, Scotland
[4] Univ Liverpool, Dept Comp Sci, Liverpool L69 3BX, Merseyside, England
来源：
JOURNAL OF LOGIC AND COMPUTATION | 2015年 / 25卷 / 05期
关键词：
Argumentation; legal case-based reasoning; MODEL;
D O I：
10.1093/logcom/ext010
中图分类号：
TP301 [理论、方法];
学科分类号：
081202 ;
摘要：
In this article we offer a formal account of reasoning with legal cases in terms of argumentation schemes. These schemes, and undercutting attacks associated with them, are formalized as defeasible rules of inference within the ASPIC+ framework. We begin by modelling the style of reasoning with cases developed by Aleven and Ashley in the CATO project, which describes cases using factors, and then extend the account to accommodate the dimensions used in Rissland and Ashley's earlier HYPO project. Some additional scope for argumentation is then identified and formalized.
引用
收藏
页码：1141 / 1166
页数：26
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Argument Schemes for Legal Case-based Reasoning
    Wyner, Adam
    Bench-Capon, Trevor
    [J]. LEGAL KNOWLEDGE AND INFORMATION SYSTEMS, 2007, 165 : 139 - 149
  • [2] An ASPIC-based legal argumentation framework for deontic reasoning
    Van der Torre, Leendert
    Villata, Serena
    [J]. COMPUTATIONAL MODELS OF ARGUMENT, 2014, 266 : 421 - 432
  • [3] Abstract Argumentation for Case-Based Reasoning
    Cyras, Kristijonas
    Satoh, Ken
    Toni, Francesca
    [J]. FIFTEENTH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON THE PRINCIPLES OF KNOWLEDGE REPRESENTATION AND REASONING, 2016, : 549 - 552
  • [4] Legal case-based reasoning as practical reasoning
    Atkinson, Katie
    Bench-Capon, Trevor
    [J]. ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND LAW, 2005, 13 (01) : 93 - 131
  • [5] A possibilistic formalization of case-based reasoning and decision making
    Hullermeier, Eyke
    [J]. COMPUTATIONAL INTELLIGENCE: THEORY AND APPLICATIONS, 1999, 1625 : 411 - 420
  • [6] Learning Case Relevance in Case-Based Reasoning with Abstract Argumentation
    Paulino-Passos, Guilherme
    Toni, Francesca
    [J]. LEGAL KNOWLEDGE AND INFORMATION SYSTEMS, 2023, 379 : 95 - 100
  • [7] Using case-based reasoning for argumentation with multiple viewpoints
    Karacapilidis, N
    Trousse, B
    Papadias, D
    [J]. CASE-BASED REASONING RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT, 1997, 1266 : 541 - 552
  • [8] Explanation for Case-Based Reasoning via Abstract Argumentation
    Cyras, Kristijonas
    Satoh, Ken
    Toni, Francesca
    [J]. COMPUTATIONAL MODELS OF ARGUMENT, 2016, 287 : 243 - 254
  • [9] An ontology in OWL for legal case-based reasoning
    Wyner, Adam
    [J]. ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND LAW, 2008, 16 (04) : 361 - 387
  • [10] Inferring New Classifications in Legal Case-Based Reasoning
    Di Florio, Cecilia
    Liu, Xinghan
    Lorini, Emiliano
    Rotolo, Antonino
    Sartor, Giovanni
    [J]. LEGAL KNOWLEDGE AND INFORMATION SYSTEMS, 2023, 379 : 23 - 32
12345