Is there a "disability" for learning a foreign language?

被引:22
|
作者
Sparks, Richard L. [1 ]
机构
[1] Coll Mt St Joseph, Cincinnati, OH 45233 USA
关键词
D O I
10.1177/00222194060390060601
中图分类号
G76 [特殊教育];
学科分类号
040109 ;
摘要
Recently, talk of a new type of learning disability (LD)-a foreign language learning disability, or FLLD-has made its way into the LD and foreign language (FL) literature. However, no empirical evidence has been published to support the concept of a "disability" for FL learning by those professionals who use the term. In this article, the author takes the position that there is not a distinct "disability" that can be called an FLLD. He reviews several years of research evidence indicating that any proposal for such a distinct entity is problematic. To support his position, he reviews problems with the current definition and diagnostic criteria for LD. He then cites the many difficulties inherent in the development and use of (a) a logically consistent, easily operationalized, and empirically valid definition of and (b) diagnostic criteria for the FLLD concept. The author then discusses how FL learning problems occur along a continuum of very strong to very poor language learners, and he explains how the proponents of an FLLD misuse the concept of FL aptitude. Finally, the author cites implications resulting from the research evidence on FL learning problems and use of the term FLLD.
引用
收藏
页码:544 / 557
页数:14
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] IDENTIFYING NATIVE LANGUAGE DIFFICULTIES AMONG FOREIGN-LANGUAGE LEARNERS IN COLLEGE - A FOREIGN-LANGUAGE LEARNING-DISABILITY
    GANSCHOW, L
    SPARKS, RL
    JAVORSKY, J
    POHLMAN, J
    BISHOPMARBURY, A
    [J]. JOURNAL OF LEARNING DISABILITIES, 1991, 24 (09) : 530 - 541
  • [2] Foreign Language Learning
    Angulo-Jimenez, Henry
    Bonilla-Lopez, Marisela
    Rojas-Ramirez, Esteban
    [J]. TOPICS IN LANGUAGE DISORDERS, 2024, 44 (01) : 44 - 62
  • [3] Learning a foreign language
    Doke, C. M.
    [J]. AFRICAN STUDIES, 1950, 9 (02) : 98 - 98
  • [4] On Learning a Foreign Language
    Pargment, M. S.
    [J]. MODERN LANGUAGE JOURNAL, 1945, 29 (03): : 198 - 209
  • [5] Learning a Foreign Language
    Capell, A.
    [J]. OCEANIA, 1950, 21 (01) : 79 - 80
  • [6] LANGUAGE USE AND FOREIGN LANGUAGE LEARNING
    OLLER, JW
    [J]. IRAL-INTERNATIONAL REVIEW OF APPLIED LINGUISTICS IN LANGUAGE TEACHING, 1971, 9 (02): : 161 - 168
  • [7] Language disability and learning difficulties
    Maccuspie-Moore, C
    [J]. AUSTRALIAN JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY, 2001, 53 : 195 - 195
  • [8] Specific language impairment as a language learning disability
    Bishop, Dorothy V. M.
    [J]. CHILD LANGUAGE TEACHING & THERAPY, 2009, 25 (02): : 163 - 165
  • [9] Learning Community in Foreign Language Learning
    Zhang, Yuhuan
    [J]. PROCEEDINGS OF THE INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON ELECTRONICS, MECHANICS, CULTURE AND MEDICINE, 2016, 45 : 394 - 397
  • [10] Subtitling in foreign language learning
    Gonzalez-Vera, Pilar
    [J]. TRANS-REVISTA DE TRADUCTOLOGIA, 2013, (17): : 247 - 248