The relation between the dignity of the disabled person and the value of human embryos

被引:0
|
作者
Sanches, Mario Antonio [1 ]
Simao-Silva, Daiane Priscila [1 ]
de Oliveira, Houda Izabela [1 ]
机构
[1] Pontificia Univ Catolica Parana, Curitiba, PR, Brazil
来源
关键词
Bioethics; Eugenics; Genetic Testing; Symbolic Violence; MATERNAL PLASMA; DIAGNOSIS; DISABILITY; POLICIES; RISKS; DNA;
D O I
10.11606/issn.2316-9044.v20i2p134-154
中图分类号
D9 [法律]; DF [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
In the last few decades, it has been notorious the increased offer of genetic testing for prenatal diagnosis as well as their application for pregnancy interruption or discarding embryos in assisted reproduction. At the same time, many movements and organizations have emerged to affirm the dignity of people with disabilities and their right to the full inclusion of their lives in society. This article intends to analyze these two movements and highlight their contradictions. We question whether it is possible to dissociate the anomalous embryo and fetus disposal practices from eugenics' assumptions of the early twentieth century, and the consistency of such practices. The deliberation is conducted considering that clearly we are looking at movements that point to opposite directions and the discussion needs to be expanded coherently. Movements in favor of people with disabilities have already achieved many legislative and political advances in recent decades, however, they still have a lot to confront in relation to the medical or deterministic model of disability, which has been built and socially reinforced pointing disability as a problem to be eliminated. This discourse peaks with the legitimacy conferred to genetic testing as a way of overcoming the problem of disabilities by eliminating the "disabled" themselves.
引用
收藏
页码:134 / 154
页数:21
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Care of the older person and the value of human dignity
    Pageau, Felix
    Fiasse, Gaelle
    Nordenfelt, Lennart
    Mihailov, Emilian
    [J]. BIOETHICS, 2024, 38 (01) : 44 - 51
  • [2] Dependency as a Virtue: The Interplay Between the Dignity of the Human Person and the Value of the Common Good
    Toates, Sarah E.
    [J]. LINACRE QUARTERLY, 2023,
  • [3] HOW UNTOUCHABLE IS HUMAN DIGNITY? THE CONNECTION BETWEEN HUMAN DIGNITY, THE PERSON AND NATURE IN BIOETHICS
    Schockenhoff, Eberhard
    [J]. BOGOSLOVSKA SMOTRA-EPHEMERIDES THEOLOGICAE ZAGRABIENSES, 2007, 77 (01): : 5 - 21
  • [4] THE DIGNITY OF THE HUMAN PERSON
    不详
    [J]. SOCIOLOGY AND SOCIAL RESEARCH, 1955, 40 (01): : 69 - 69
  • [5] The Value and Dignity of Human What it means, valuing a Person in itself?
    Weber-Guskar, Eva
    [J]. DEUTSCHE ZEITSCHRIFT FUR PHILOSOPHIE, 2013, 61 (01): : 109 - 125
  • [6] The Human Dignity of Person with Autism
    Strelhow, Thyeles Borcarte
    [J]. REVELETEO-REVISTA ELECTRONICA ESPACO TEOLOGICO, 2012, 6 (10): : 44 - 60
  • [7] Euthanasia in Brazil: between the Criminal Code and the dignity of the human person
    da Silva Barbosa, Gabriella Sousa
    Losurdo, Federico
    [J]. REVISTA DE INVESTIGACOES CONSTITUCIONAIS-JOURNAL OF CONSTITUTIONAL RESEARCH, 2018, 5 (02): : 165 - 186
  • [8] RESEARCH ON EMBRYOS AND HUMAN DIGNITY
    Duttge, Gunnar
    [J]. ISRAEL LAW REVIEW, 2009, 42 (02) : 398 - 415
  • [9] THE DIGNITY OF THE HUMAN PERSON - CRONAN,EP
    NAVONE, JJ
    [J]. PHILOSOPHY AND PHENOMENOLOGICAL RESEARCH, 1956, 17 (01) : 135 - 136
  • [10] Disabled-Long Throw and human Dignity
    Wildner, Manfred
    [J]. GESUNDHEITSWESEN, 2020, 82 (02) : 123 - 125