Transformation of immigrant integration - Civic integration and antidiscrimination in the Netherlands, France, and Germany

This article argues that, beginning in the mid-1990s, there has been a transformation of immigrant integration policies in Western Europe, away from distinct "national models" and toward convergent policies of "civic intcgratior ' for newcomers and "antidiscriminafior ' for settled immigrants and their descendants. This convergence is demonstrated by a least-likely case comparison of the Netherlands, France, and Germany states that had pursued sharply different lines in the past. The author fleshes out the conflicting, even contradictory logics of antidiscrimination and civic integration and grounds them in opposite variants of liberalism, an "old" liberalism of nondiscrimination and equal opportunity and a "new" liberalism of power and disciplining, respectively.