Roles of traditional medicine and traditional healers for rabies prevention and potential impacts on post-exposure prophylaxis: A literature review

被引:10
|
作者
Beasley, Erin A. [1 ,2 ]
Wallace, Ryan M. [1 ]
Coetzer, Andre [3 ,4 ]
Nel, Louis H. [3 ,4 ]
Pieracci, Emily G. [1 ]
机构
[1] Ctr Dis Control & Prevent, Natl Ctr Emerging & Zoonot Infect Dis, Atlanta, GA 30333 USA
[2] Ctr Dis Control & Prevent, Ctr Surveillance Epidmiol & Lab Serv, Atlanta, GA 30333 USA
[3] Global Alliance Rabies Control, Pretoria, South Africa
[4] Univ Pretoria, Dept Biochem Genet & Microbiol, Fac Nat & Agr Sci, Pretoria, South Africa
来源
PLOS NEGLECTED TROPICAL DISEASES | 2022年 / 16卷 / 01期
关键词
DOG-BITE; MANAGEMENT; KNOWLEDGE; AWARENESS; PLANTS;
D O I
10.1371/journal.pntd.0010087
中图分类号
R51 [传染病];
学科分类号
100401 ;
摘要
IntroductionGlobally, traditional medicine is widely used to treat a variety of injuries and illnesses, including dog bites, and exposures that are risky for rabies. However, efficacy of most traditional remedies used for rabies prevention or treatment has not been demonstrated in controlled trials or proven in community-based surveys. MethodsSix databases were searched including the terms rabies, traditional treatment, traditional remedy, traditional therapy, traditional medicine, and medicinal treatment to review traditional remedies used in the prevention and treatment of rabies. In addition, published literature of rabies transmission dynamics was used to estimate statistical likelihood of dog bite victims developing rabies to provide clarity as to why traditional healers have a high apparent success rate when preventing death from rabies in victims bitten by suspected rabid dogs. ResultsLiterature review yielded 50 articles, including three controlled experiments, that described use of traditional remedies for rabies prevention and treatment. Traditional remedies for rabies ranged from plant- or animal-based products to spiritual rituals; however, only a few controlled mice trials were conducted, and none of these trials demonstrated efficacy in preventing or treating rabies. Risk of dying from rabies after a bite from a dog with unknown rabies status is low, 1.90% (0.05%-29.60%). Therefore, traditional healers had a 98.10% (70.40%-99.95%) apparent success rate in preventing death from suspected rabid dog bites despite inefficaciousness of herbal remedies. ConclusionThere was no universal plant species or route of administration that was consistently used for rabies prevention or treatment across countries. No traditional remedy was efficacious in the prevention or treatment of rabies in randomized controlled experiments. Understanding the cultural context under which traditional remedies are used may facilitate collaboration of traditional healers with the modern medical system to ensure timely and appropriate use of proven therapies for prevention and clinical management of rabies. Author summaryTraditional medicine is commonly used worldwide for a variety of ailments and diseases, including animal bite wound care and pre-clinical rabies prevention. Traditional healers often use herbal-based remedies containing local plants. Other traditional remedies include animal-based or spiritual-based methods. This literature review included plant surveys, controlled mice experiments, and community-based studies concerning rabies prevention provided by traditional healers in multiple countries. There was no consistent remedy used across the published literature, and most importantly, there were no published studies supporting effective traditional medicine methods for use in the prevention or treatment of human rabies. Our review of rabies virus transmission rates show that traditional healers have a high apparent success rate of preventing rabies deaths from dog bites, but there is no scientific or medical basis for this perception. Educating communities about proven, effective rabies prevention through post-exposure prophylaxis while understanding the cultural importance of traditional medicine is needed for promoting effective rabies prevention.
引用
收藏
页数:18
相关论文
共 21 条
  • [1] Post-exposure rabies prophylaxis for mass bat exposures: Case series and systematic review
    Choe, Young June
    Teevan, Bridget
    Smit, Michael
    Quilliam, Daniela
    Bandy, Utpala
    Mermel, Leonard
    ZOONOSES AND PUBLIC HEALTH, 2020, 67 (04) : 331 - 341
  • [2] Evaluating the benefit of serology during potential Australian bat lyssavirus and rabies post-exposure prophylaxis
    Harris, James
    Uren, Alexandra
    Smith, James
    Titmus, Emily
    Young, Megan
    AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, 2023, 47 (06)
  • [3] A retrospective review of rabies post-exposure prophylaxis queries, South Africa, 2016-2019
    Whitbread, Trisha A.
    Kabuya, Kathleen J.
    Naran, Nimesh
    Juggernath, Amilcar M.
    Mathews, Moushumi A.
    Blumberg, Lucille H.
    Weyer, Jacqueline
    Essel, Vivien
    SOUTHERN AFRICAN JOURNAL OF INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2022, 37 (01)
  • [4] Potential option for rabies post-exposure prophylaxis: New vaccine with PIKA adjuvant against diverse Chinese rabies strains
    Yu, Pengcheng
    Liu, Yuan
    Tao, Xiaoyan
    He, Ying
    Liu, Qian
    Wang, Bin
    Zheng, Huiyu
    Zhang, Nan
    Bi, Shengli
    Zhu, Wuyang
    Zhang, Yi
    VACCINE, 2023, 41 (46) : 6852 - 6862
  • [5] Post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP) for rabies with purified chick embryo cell vaccine: a systematic literature review and meta-analysis
    Preiss, Scott
    Chanthavanich, Pornthep
    Chen, Lin H.
    Marano, Cinzia
    Buchy, Philippe
    van Hoorn, Rosa
    Noordegraaf, Marije Vonk
    Mukherjee, Piyali
    EXPERT REVIEW OF VACCINES, 2018, 17 (06) : 525 - 545
  • [6] Maoto, a traditional herbal medicine, for post-exposure prophylaxis for Japanese healthcare workers exposed to COVID-19: A single center study
    Nabeshima, Atsuko
    Sakamoto, Atsuhiko
    Iwata, Kaoru
    Kitamura, Yuji
    Masui, Shinta
    Inomata, Shinjiro
    Iida, Masahiro
    Iida, Takeshi
    Nabeshima, Shigeki
    JOURNAL OF INFECTION AND CHEMOTHERAPY, 2022, 28 (07) : 907 - 911
  • [7] The potential effect of improved provision of rabies post-exposure prophylaxis in Gavi-eligible countries: a modelling study
    Hampson, Katie
    Trotter, Caroline
    LANCET INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2019, 19 (01): : 102 - 111
  • [8] Determinants of delay in initiating post-exposure prophylaxis for rabies prevention among animal bite cases: Hospital based study
    Joseph, Jessy
    Sangeetha, N.
    Khan, Amir Maroof
    Rajoura, O. P.
    VACCINE, 2013, 32 (01) : 74 - 77
  • [9] Human rabies despite post-exposure prophylaxis: a systematic review of fatal breakthrough infections after zoonotic exposures
    Whitehouse, Erin R.
    Mandra, Anna
    Bonwitt, Jesse
    Beasley, Erin A.
    Taliano, Joanna
    Rao, Agam K.
    LANCET INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2023, 23 (05): : E167 - E174
  • [10] Human Methylmercury Exposure and Potential Impacts in Central Tibet: Food and Traditional Tibetan Medicine
    Cheng, Menghan
    Liu, Maodian
    Li, Dou
    Luo, Qing
    Zhang, Zhihao
    Yuan, Liuliang
    Yu, Chenghao
    Xie, Han
    Lin, Huiming
    Zhang, Qianru
    Ji, De
    Wang, Xuejun
    BULLETIN OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONTAMINATION AND TOXICOLOGY, 2021, 107 (03) : 449 - 458