Comparison of immunoassay and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry for measurement of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in contaminated soil

Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are frequently encountered in the environment and may pose health concerns due to their carcinogenicity. A commercial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), was evaluated as a screening method for monitoring PAHs at contaminated sites. The ELISA was a carcinogenic PAH (C-PAH) RaPID assay testing kit that cross-reacts with several PAHs and utilizes benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) as a calibrator. Soil samples were extracted with 50% acetone in dichloromethane (DCM) for analysis by ELISA and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS). The overall method precision was within +/-30% for ELISA and within +/-20% for GC-MS. Recovery data for spiked soils ranged from 46 to 140% for BaP as determined by ELISA. Recoveries data of the GC-MS surrogate standards, 2-fluorobiphenyl and chrysene, were greater than 70%. The GC-MS procedure detected a total of 19 priority PAHs (2-6-ring PAHs) including seven probable human carcinogens (4-6-ring B2-PAHs). The ELISA results were compared to GC-MS summation results for the total 19 target PAHs as well as for the subset of the seven B2-PAH compounds. For all soil samples, the PAH concentrations derived from ELISA were greater than the sum of B2-PAH concentrations obtained by GC-MS. ELISA determinations were also frequently greater than the results obtained by GC-MS for the total 19 PAH compounds. This discrepancy can be expected, since the ELISA is a screening assay for the detection of several related PAHs while the GC-MS procedure detects priority PAH compounds. Thus, only a subset of PAHs (e.g. 19 PAHs) in the soil samples were measured by GC-MS while additional PAHs, including alkylated PAHs, and PAH derivatives have been demonstrated to be cross-reactive in the C-PAH ELISA. Results of paired tests show that the PAH data from ELISA and GC-MS methods are significantly different (P < 0.001), but highly correlated. The ELISA data had a strong positive relationship with the GC-MS summation data for the B2-PAHs as well as for the 19 PAHs targeted by the GC-MS method. Results indicate that the ELISA may be useful as a broad screen for monitoring PAHs in environmental samples. (C) 2003 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.