Hempel's Standard Examples of Non-causal Explanation in the Light of Skow's Theory of Causal Explanation

被引:1
|
作者
Makovnik, Dalibor [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Komenskeho Bratislave, Filozoficka Fak, Katedra Logiky & Metodol Vied, Gondova 2, Bratislava 81499, Slovakia
来源
FILOZOFIA | 2022年 / 77卷 / 05期
关键词
Non-causal explanation; Partial causal explanation; Differential equations; Scientific law; Galilean idealization; Explanation of particular events;
D O I
10.31577/filozofia.2022.77.5.1
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
The paper attempts to respond to some possible objections that could be raised by Skow's theory of explanation against the two standard examples of non-causal explanation given by Hempel. If these objections would prevail the two standard non-causal examples could be reconstructed as causal explanations. In this paper it is argued that this kind of reconstruction is not possible. The article starts with a detailed analysis of Skow's theory of causal explanation. Subsequently it tries to show that each of Hempel's examples put up against the potential objections that could be given in terms of Skow's theory is ultimately resistant to these objections. Finally, the paper's conclusion is that Skow's theory although an interesting approach for reconstructing causal explanations fails as an adequate framework for reconstructing Hempel's standard examples of non-causal explanation.
引用
收藏
页码:311 / 324
页数:14
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Non-causal Explanation: Hempel's Legacy and its Modern Versions
    Makovnik, Dalibor
    [J]. FILOZOFIA, 2021, 76 (10): : 752 - 765
  • [2] Hamilton's rule: A non-causal explanation?
    Koliofotis, Vaios
    Verreault-Julien, Philippe
    [J]. STUDIES IN HISTORY AND PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 2022, 92 : 109 - 118
  • [3] Explanation in Computational Neuroscience: Causal and Non-causal
    Chirimuuta, M.
    [J]. BRITISH JOURNAL FOR THE PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 2018, 69 (03): : 849 - 880
  • [4] A TYPE OF NON-CAUSAL EXPLANATION
    ACHINSTEIN, P
    [J]. MIDWEST STUDIES IN PHILOSOPHY, 1984, 9 : 221 - 243
  • [5] Explanatory Asymmetry in Non-Causal Explanation
    Andrew Wayne
    [J]. Journal for General Philosophy of Science, 2022, 53 : 555 - 571
  • [6] NON-CAUSAL EXPLANATION OF HUMAN ACTION
    NATHAN, NML
    [J]. PHILOSOPHY OF THE SOCIAL SCIENCES, 1976, 6 (03) : 241 - 243
  • [7] Explanatory Asymmetry in Non-Causal Explanation
    Wayne, Andrew
    [J]. JOURNAL FOR GENERAL PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 2022, 53 (04) : 555 - 571
  • [8] The Prospects for a Monist Theory of Non-causal Explanation in Science and Mathematics
    Alexander Reutlinger
    Mark Colyvan
    Karolina Krzyżanowska
    [J]. Erkenntnis, 2022, 87 : 1773 - 1793
  • [9] The Prospects for a Monist Theory of Non-causal Explanation in Science and Mathematics
    Reutlinger, Alexander
    Colyvan, Mark
    Krzyzanowska, Karolina
    [J]. ERKENNTNIS, 2022, 87 (04) : 1773 - 1793
  • [10] Does the counterfactual theory of explanation apply to non-causal explanations in metaphysics?
    Reutlinger, Alexander
    [J]. EUROPEAN JOURNAL FOR PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE, 2017, 7 (02) : 239 - 256