Bathymetric Photogrammetry to Update CHS Charts: Comparing Conventional 3D Manual and Automatic Approaches

被引:10
|
作者
Chenier, Rene [1 ]
Faucher, Marc-Andre [1 ]
Ahola, Ryan [1 ]
Shelat, Yask [1 ]
Sagram, Mesha [1 ]
机构
[1] Canadian Hydrog Serv, 200 Kent St, Ottawa, ON K1A 0E6, Canada
来源
关键词
satellite derived bathymetry (SDB); stereo photogrammetry; Canadian Hydrographic Service; navigational charts; Canadian Arctic; WATER DEPTH; GEOPOSITIONING ACCURACY; MUTUAL INFORMATION; IMAGERY; GEOMETRY; IKONOS;
D O I
10.3390/ijgi7100395
中图分类号
TP [自动化技术、计算机技术];
学科分类号
0812 ;
摘要
The Canadian Hydrographic Service (CHS) supports safe navigation within Canadian waters through approximately 1000 navigational charts as well as hundreds of publications. One of the greatest challenges faced by the CHS is removing gaps in bathymetric survey data, particularly in the Canadian Arctic where only 6% of navigational water is surveyed to modern standards. Therefore, the CHS has initiated a research project to explore remote sensing methods to improve Canadian navigational charts. The major components of this project explore satellite derived bathymetry (SDB), coastline change detection and coastline extraction. This paper focuses on the potential of two stereo satellite techniques for deriving SDB: (i) automatic digital elevation model (DEM) extraction using a semi-global matching method, and (ii) 3D manual delineation of depth contours using visual stereoscopic interpretation. Analysis focused on quantitative assessment which compared estimated depths from both automatic and 3D manual photogrammetric approaches against available in situ survey depths. The results indicate that the 3D manual approach provides an accuracy of <2 m up to a depth of 15 m. Comparable results were obtained from the automatic approach to a depth of 12 m. For almost all investigated depth ranges for both techniques, uncertainties were found to be within the required vertical accuracies for the International Hydrographic Organization category zone of confidence (CATZOC) level C classification for hydrographic surveys. This indicates that both techniques can be used to derive navigational quality bathymetric information within the investigated study site. While encouraging, neither technique was found to offer a single solution for the complete estimation of depth within the study area. As a result of these findings, the CHS envisions a hybrid approach where stereo- and reflectance-based bathymetry estimation techniques are implemented to provide the greatest understanding of depth possible from satellite imagery. Overall, stereo photogrammetry techniques will likely allow for new potential for supporting the improvement of CHS charts in areas where modern surveys have not yet been obtained.
引用
收藏
页数:14
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] An update on automatic 3D building reconstruction
    Haala, Norbert
    Kada, Martin
    ISPRS JOURNAL OF PHOTOGRAMMETRY AND REMOTE SENSING, 2010, 65 (06) : 570 - 580
  • [2] Forensic 3D documentation of skin injuries using photogrammetry: photographs vs video and manual vs automatic measurements
    Flies, Mitchell J.
    Larsen, Peter K.
    Lynnerup, Niels
    Villa, Chiara
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LEGAL MEDICINE, 2019, 133 (03) : 963 - 971
  • [3] Forensic 3D documentation of skin injuries using photogrammetry: photographs vs video and manual vs automatic measurements
    Mitchell J. Flies
    Peter K. Larsen
    Niels Lynnerup
    Chiara Villa
    International Journal of Legal Medicine, 2019, 133 : 963 - 971
  • [4] Sagittal Craniosynostosis: Comparing Surgical Techniques Using 3D Photogrammetry
    Abdel-Alim, Tareq
    Kurniawan, Melissa
    Mathijssen, Irene
    Dremmen, Marjolein
    Dirven, Clemens
    Niessen, Wiro
    Roshchupkin, Gennady
    van Veelen, Marie-Lise
    PLASTIC AND RECONSTRUCTIVE SURGERY, 2023, 152 (04) : 675E - 688E
  • [5] BATHYMETRIC SURVEYING IN LAKE SUPERIOR: 3D MODELING AND SONAR EQUIPMENTS COMPARING
    Levin, E.
    Meadows, G.
    Shults, R.
    Karacelebi, U.
    Kulunk, H. S.
    UNDERWATER 3D RECORDING AND MODELLING: A TOOL FOR MODERN APPLICATIONS AND CH RECORDING, 2019, 42-2 (W10): : 101 - 106
  • [6] Comparing Quality of Aerial Photogrammetry and 3D Laser Scanning Methods for Creating 3D Models of Objects
    Daugela, Ignas
    Suziedelyte-Visockiene, Jurate
    Stanionis, Arminas
    Tumeliene, Egle
    Antanaviciute, Urte
    Aksamitauskas, Vladislovas Ceslovas
    10TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING (10TH ICEE), 2017,
  • [7] Comparative Analysis of Terrestrial Semi-automatic and Automatic Photogrammetry in 3D Modeling Process
    Sonja Krasić
    Petar Pejić
    Nexus Network Journal, 2014, 16 : 273 - 283
  • [8] Comparative Analysis of Terrestrial Semi-automatic and Automatic Photogrammetry in 3D Modeling Process
    Krasic, Sonja
    Pejic, Petar
    NEXUS NETWORK JOURNAL, 2014, 16 (02) : 273 - 283
  • [9] Comparing calibration approaches for 3D ultrasound probes
    Bergmeir, C.
    Seitel, M.
    Frank, C.
    De Simone, R.
    Meinzer, H. -P.
    Wolf, I.
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF COMPUTER ASSISTED RADIOLOGY AND SURGERY, 2009, 4 (02) : 203 - 213
  • [10] Comparing calibration approaches for 3D ultrasound probes
    C. Bergmeir
    M. Seitel
    C. Frank
    R. De Simone
    H.-P. Meinzer
    I. Wolf
    International Journal of Computer Assisted Radiology and Surgery, 2009, 4 : 203 - 213