Freud's Moses and Fromm's Freud: Erich Fromm's silence on Freud's Moses - a silence of negation or a silence of consent?

被引:1
|
作者
Pinkas, Ronen [1 ]
机构
[1] Potsdam Univ, Sch Jewish Theol, Potsdam, Germany
关键词
Judaism and psychoanalysis; Moses and monotheism; Jewish philosophy; PROPHETIC MESSIANISM; FREUD; SIGMUND;
D O I
10.1080/21692327.2022.2140184
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
In 1939 Sigmund Freud published his latest book, Moses and Monotheism, which is his most unusual and problematic work. In Moses Freud offers four groundbreaking claims in regard to the biblical story: [a] Moses was an Egyptian [b] The origin of monotheism is not Judaism [c] Moses was murdered by the Jews [d] The murder sparked a constant sense of unconscious guilt, which eventually contributed to the rational and ethical development of Jewish monotheism. As is well known, Freud's Moses received extremely negative reviews from Jewish thinkers. The social psychoanalyst, Erich Fromm, who wrote extensively on Freud as well as on Judaism and the biblical narrative, did not explicitly express his position on Freud's latest work. This paper offers explanations for Fromm's roaring silence on Freud's Moses.
引用
收藏
页码:240 / 262
页数:23
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] On Freud's "Moses and Monotheism"
    Paul, Robert A.
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PSYCHOANALYSIS, 2024, 105 (02): : 271 - 274
  • [2] Rereading Freud's 'Moses' (again) (Sigmund!Freud)
    Reitter, Paul
    [J]. GERMANIC REVIEW, 2008, 83 (01): : 11 - 23
  • [3] Language?s navel in Freud?s Moses
    Martins, Alessandra Affortunati
    [J]. JOURNAL OF PSYCHOSOCIAL STUDIES, 2023, 16 (01): : 78 - 93
  • [4] Freud's Moses, Schoenberg's Moses, and the Tragic Quest for Purity
    Cooper-White, Pamela
    [J]. AMERICAN IMAGO, 2022, 79 (01) : 89 - 122
  • [5] Freud's Moses: an imperceptible identity
    Henry, A
    Baranger, JP
    [J]. ANNALES MEDICO-PSYCHOLOGIQUES, 1999, 157 (01): : 62 - 65
  • [6] MISSION OF FREUD,S - FRENCH - FROMM,E
    MALLET, RAV
    [J]. ANNEE PSYCHOLOGIQUE, 1977, 77 (01): : 282 - 282
  • [7] MOSES AND MONOTHEISM - FRENCH - FREUD,S
    PACHET, P
    [J]. CRITIQUE, 1976, 32 (346) : 317 - 323
  • [8] Moses Freud's ultimate project
    Nurmela, Risto Olavi
    [J]. JEWISH STUDIES IN THE NORDIC COUNTRIES TODAY, 2016, 27 : 223 - 242
  • [9] Beyond Freud's instinctivism and Fromm's existential humanism
    Cortina, M
    [J]. PROPHETIC ANALYST - ERICH FROMM'S CONTRIBUTION TO PSYCHOANALYSIS, 1996, : 93 - 131
  • [10] Michelangelo's Moses and Freud's "daring deed"
    Oliner, Marion M.
    [J]. PSYCHOANALYTIC QUARTERLY, 2008, 77 (02): : 648 - 652