An inter- and intra-observer test of the computer program CRANID

被引：1
|
作者：
Lee, Matthew [1 ]
Gerdau-Radonic, Karina [2 ]
机构：
[1] Bournemouth Univ, Dept Archaeol Anthropol & Forens Sci, Fern Barrow, Poole BH12 5BB, Dorset, England
[2] Univ Strasbourg, UMR Archimede Archeol & Hist Ancienne 7044, Mediterranee Europe MISHA, 5 Allee Gal Rouvillois,CS 50008, F-67083 Strasbourg, France
来源：
FORENSIC SCIENCE INTERNATIONAL | 2022年 / 337卷
关键词：
Craniometrics; Ancestry estimation; CRANID; Inter -observer effects; Intra-observer effects; BRONZE-AGE; MIGRATION; ANCESTRY; STATURE; CLASSIFICATION;
D O I：
10.1016/j.forsciint.2022.111375
中图分类号：
DF [法律]; D9 [法律]; R [医药、卫生];
学科分类号：
0301 ; 10 ;
摘要：
The use of cranial analysis, through metric and/or morphological data, remains a popular method within biological anthropology and its subfields to allow for the analysis of an individual. These methods in-creasingly use multivariate statistics to empirically measure the degree of similarities between individuals and populations. CRANID is a piece of freeware which allows the user to estimate ancestry from 29 cranial measurements. This paper utilised a previously published dataset (Lee and Gerdau 2020 [29]) of cranial measurements to simulate multiple users estimating the ancestry for a single cranium of known origin. Only 32-68 % of the generated ancestry estimations were found to match the broad geographic region of the tested cranium depending on the statistical test. This paper also highlights aspects of CRANID's results that may make it harder for users to understand the results the program provides.(c) 2022 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页数：9
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Inter- and intra-observer reliability of ASPECTS
    Hill, MD
    Barber, PA
    Hudon, ME
    Pexman, JHW
    [J]. STROKE, 2003, 34 (01) : 281 - 282
  • [2] Inter- and intra-observer variation in phytolith morphometry
    Out, Welmoed A.
    Evett, Rand
    Hoskova, Kristyna
    Power, Robert C.
    Ruiz-Perez, Javier
    Tromp, Monica
    Vrydaghs, Luc
    Wade, Kali
    Hasler, Mario
    [J]. ANNALS OF BOTANY, 2024,
  • [3] INTER- AND INTRA-OBSERVER AGREEMENT IN THE MILCH AND WEISS SYSTEMS
    Charles Lozoya, Sergio
    Trevino Baez, Joaquin Dario
    Rangel Flores, Jesus Maria
    Brizuela Ventura, Jesus Miguel
    Araiza Topete, Omar
    Alcazar Juarez, Andrea
    [J]. ACTA ORTOPEDICA BRASILEIRA, 2018, 26 (04): : 218 - 221
  • [4] Inter- and Intra-Observer Variations in the Delineation of Lesions in Mammograms
    Buelow, Thomas
    Heese, Harald S.
    Grewer, Ruediger
    Kutra, Dominik
    Wiemker, Rafael
    [J]. MEDICAL IMAGING 2015: IMAGE PERCEPTION, OBSERVER PERFORMANCE, AND TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT, 2015, 9416
  • [5] Inter- and intra-observer variability of glenoid track measurements
    Schneider, Adrian
    Hoy, Gregory A.
    Ek, Eugene T.
    Rotstein, Andrew H.
    Tate, Julie
    Taylor, David McD
    Evans, Matthew C.
    [J]. SWISS MEDICAL WEEKLY, 2017, 147 : 41S - 41S
  • [6] Inter- and intra-observer variation in the reporting of cervical smears
    Smith, JHF
    [J]. CYTOPATHOLOGY, 1997, 8 (01) : 68 - 69
  • [7] Inter- and Intra-observer Agreement of the Motion Palpation Test for Lumbar Vertebral Rotational Asymmetry
    Bracht, Marcelo Anderson
    Nunes, Guilherme S.
    Celestino, Jardel
    Schwertner, Debora Soccal
    Franca, Leandro Cardoso
    de Noronha, Marcos
    [J]. PHYSIOTHERAPY CANADA, 2015, 67 (02) : 169 - 173
  • [8] Intrapartum ultrasound for cervical dilatation: Inter- and intra-observer agreement
    Hanidu, Arwa
    Kovalenko, Mariya
    Usman, Sana
    Monasta, Lorenzo
    Zamagni, Giulia
    Stampalija, Tamara
    Lees, Christoph
    [J]. ACTA OBSTETRICIA ET GYNECOLOGICA SCANDINAVICA, 2024,
  • [9] Evaluation of oral mucosal diseases: inter- and intra-observer analyses
    Zadik, Yehuda
    Orbach, Hadas
    Panzok, Amy
    Smith, Yoav
    Czerninski, Rakefet
    [J]. JOURNAL OF ORAL PATHOLOGY & MEDICINE, 2012, 41 (01) : 68 - 72
  • [10] Inter- and intra-observer variability in the qualitative categorization of coronary angiograms
    Herrman, JPR
    Azar, A
    Umans, VAWM
    Boersma, E
    vonEs, GA
    Serruys, PW
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CARDIAC IMAGING, 1996, 12 (01): : 21 - 30
12345