Comparative seismic fragility estimates of steel moment frame buildings with or without superelastic viscous dampers

Superelastic viscous damper is a passive hybrid control device that combines shape memory alloy cables and a viscoelastic damper to mitigate dynamic response of structures subjected to multi-level seismic hazards. In the hybrid device, shape memory alloy cables that exhibit a nonlinear but elastic response are used mainly as re-centering unit, while the viscoelastic damper composed of high-damped butyl rubber compounds is employed to augment the equivalent viscous damping provided by the device. This study evaluates the effectiveness of superelastic viscous dampers in mitigating seismic response of steel frame structures through a probabilistic framework. First, a nine-story steel frame building is designed and modeled with and without superelastic viscous dampers, and extensive nonlinear response-history analyses are conducted. Then, probabilistic demand models are developed for selected engineering demand parameters. To quantitatively compare the performance of the designed buildings, seismic fragility curves and mean annual frequency of exceeding different performance levels are developed. In particular, the structural performance is evaluated using both peak inter-story drift and residual drift responses. Results indicate that superelastic viscous dampers can significantly improve structural performance; thus, it has the potential to lower the post-earthquake losses, as the better structural performance leads to less loss in relocation, rental, and economic loss.