Considerations on Orthogonality Duality in Comprehensive Two-Dimensional Gas Chromatography

The term "orthogonal" in comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (GC x GC) has a double sided meaning as it stands for a separation resulting from the combination of two independent retention mechanisms (Giddings, J. C. J. High Resolut, Chromatogr. 1987, 10, 319) but also for a 2D separation where the components are evenly distributed over the entire 2D space. It is shown in the present study that a nonorthogonal GC x GC system associating a polar stationary phase in the first dimension (poly(ethylene glycol)) to a nonpolar one in the second dimension (poly(dimethyl siloxane)) leads to a structured chromatogram, a high peak capacity, and a great 2D space occupation. This idea is demonstrated through the characterization of oxygenated compounds in a coal-derived middle distillate. Results show a clear separation between oxygenated species and hydrocarbons which are classified into linear alkanes, cyclic alkanes, and aromatics. A breakthrough configuration combining a polar poly(ethylene glycol) first dimension and a trifluoropropyl methyl stationary phase in the second dimension enabled a unique identification and quantification of linear, cyclic, and aromatic alcohols. This configuration which could be considered as nonorthogonal still involves two different retention mechanisms: polarity and boiling point in the first dimension and electronic interactions in the second dimension. It is selective toward electronegative poles of alcohols and phenols. The contributions of these two configurations compared to a conventional orthogonal system as well as their roles for oxygenated compounds speciation are highlighted. This contribution is measured through three 2D space occupation factors. It appears through these two examples that orthogonality is intimately linked to analyte properties, and a general concept of dimensionality must be considered.