Sound and Complete Concolic Testing for Higher-order Functions

Higher-order functions have become a staple of modern programming languages. However, such values stymie concolic testers, as the SMT solvers at their hearts are inherently first-order. This paper lays a formal foundations for concolic testing higher-order functional programs. Three ideas enable our results: (i) our tester considers only program inputs in a canonical form; (ii) it collects novel constraints from the evaluation of the canonical inputs to search the space of inputs with partial help from an SMT solver and (iii) it collects constraints from canonical inputs even when they are arguments to concretized calls. We prove that (i) concolic evaluation is sound with respect to concrete evaluation; (ii) modulo concretization and SMT solver incompleteness, the search for a counter-example succeeds if a user program has a bug and (iii) this search amounts to directed evolution of inputs targeting hard-to-reach corners of the program.