Conscientious refusals to refer: findings from a national physician survey

被引:17
|
作者
Combs, Michael P. [1 ]
Antiel, Ryan M. [2 ]
Tilburt, Jon C. [3 ]
Mueller, Paul S. [3 ]
Curlin, Farr A. [4 ]
机构
[1] Univ Chicago, Pritzker Sch Med, Chicago, IL 60637 USA
[2] Mayo Clin & Mayo Fdn, Mayo Med Sch, Mayo Clin, Rochester, MN 55905 USA
[3] Mayo Clin, Div Gen Internal Med, Rochester, MN 55905 USA
[4] Univ Chicago, Maclean Ctr Clin Med Eth, Chicago, IL 60637 USA
基金
美国国家卫生研究院;
关键词
PATIENT AUTONOMY; OBJECTION; RELIGION; BELIEFS; ETHICS;
D O I
10.1136/jme.2010.041194
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
Background Regarding controversial medical services, many have argued that if physicians cannot in good conscience provide a legal medical intervention for which a patient is a candidate, they should refer the requesting patient to an accommodating provider. This study examines what US physicians think a doctor is obligated to do when the doctor thinks it would be immoral to provide a referral. Method The authors conducted a cross-sectional survey of a random sample of 2000 US physicians from all specialties. The primary criterion variable was agreement that physicians have a professional obligation to refer patients for all legal medical services for which the patients are candidates, even if the physician believes that such a referral is immoral. Results Of 1895 eligible physicians, 1032 (55%) responded. 57% of physicians agreed that doctors must refer patients regardless of whether or not the doctor believes the referral itself is immoral. Holding this opinion was independently associated with being more theologically pluralistic, describing oneself as sociopolitically liberal, and indicating that respect for patient autonomy is the most important bioethical principle in one's practice (multivariable ORs, 1.6-2.4). Conclusions Physicians are divided about a professional obligation to refer when the physician believes that referral itself is immoral. These data suggest there is no uncontroversial way to resolve conflicts posed when patients request interventions that their physicians cannot in good conscience provide.
引用
收藏
页码:397 / 401
页数:5
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Autonomy, religion and clinical decisions: findings from a national physician survey
    Lawrence, R. E.
    Curlin, F. A.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ETHICS, 2009, 35 (04) : 214 - 218
  • [2] Physician Understanding and Willingness to Prescribe Biosimilars: Findings from a US National Survey
    Kolbe, Allison R.
    Kearsley, Aaron
    Merchant, Lubna
    Temkin, Eva
    Patel, Archita
    Xu, Jing
    Jessup, Amber
    [J]. BIODRUGS, 2021, 35 (03) : 363 - 372
  • [3] Intentional Sedation to Unconsciousness at the End of Life: Findings From a National Physician Survey
    Putman, Michael S.
    Yoon, John D.
    Rasinski, Kenneth A.
    Curlin, Farr A.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF PAIN AND SYMPTOM MANAGEMENT, 2013, 46 (03) : 326 - 334
  • [4] Physician Understanding and Willingness to Prescribe Biosimilars: Findings from a US National Survey
    Allison R. Kolbe
    Aaron Kearsley
    Lubna Merchant
    Eva Temkin
    Archita Patel
    Jing Xu
    Amber Jessup
    [J]. BioDrugs, 2021, 35 : 363 - 372
  • [5] "Open Sesame!": Improving Access to the ECJ by Requiring National Courts to Reason their Refusals to Refer
    Krommendijk, Jasper
    [J]. EUROPEAN LAW REVIEW, 2017, 42 (01) : 46 - 62
  • [6] Quality of Physician Communication about Human Papillomavirus Vaccine: Findings from a National Survey
    Gilkey, Melissa B.
    Malo, Teri L.
    Shah, Parth D.
    Hall, Megan E.
    Brewer, Noel T.
    [J]. CANCER EPIDEMIOLOGY BIOMARKERS & PREVENTION, 2015, 24 (11) : 1673 - 1679
  • [7] ASSESSING THE QUALITY OF PHYSICIAN COMMUNICATION ABOUT HPV VACCINE: FINDINGS FROM A NATIONAL SURVEY
    Gilkey, Melissa
    Shah, Parth
    Hall, Megan
    Brewer, Noel
    [J]. ANNALS OF BEHAVIORAL MEDICINE, 2015, 49 : S87 - S87
  • [8] Artificial intelligence and the future of anesthesiology: Qualitative findings from a national survey of physician anesthesiologists
    Alamo, Carlos Estrada
    Diatta, Fortunay
    Lane-Fall, Meghan
    [J]. ANESTHESIA AND ANALGESIA, 2022, 134 (4S_SUPPL): : 46 - 46
  • [9] Nurse-Physician Relations and Quality of Nursing Care: Findings From a National Survey of Nurses
    Kenaszchuk, Chris
    Wilkins, Kathryn
    Reeves, Scott
    Zwarenstein, Merrick
    Russell, Ann
    [J]. CANADIAN JOURNAL OF NURSING RESEARCH, 2010, 42 (02) : 120 - 136