Mesh plug repair:: a simple, rapid and uncomplicated technique for inguinal hernia management

Introduction: The optimal inguinal hernia repair technique is a matter of debate. The Shouldice operation has long been regarded as the gold standard. While specialized hernia clinics have reproduced good results, a recurrence rate for trainees and non-specialized surgeons of between 10% and 15% seems to be more common. Laparoscopic hernia surgery has brought decreasing postoperative morbidity, low postoperative disability and early return to work. These advantages of a tension-free technique are due to the use of a prosthetic mesh. It is largely the efforts of Gilbert, Lichtenstein and Rutkow/Robbins which have popularized the use of prosthetic mesh by an open anterior approach in the USA. Methods: Since January 1997 we have prospectively evaluated the open mesh plug repair described by Rutkow/Robbins in Basel and Lugano. We have operated on 110 patients (103 male, 7 female). All patients were interviewed 4 weeks postoperatively at our clinic. Results: There were no major complications. Two patients underwent reoperation for drainage of a haematoma. There was no early recurrence or infection. After 4 weeks 82% of all patients were back to normal activity. An early return to work has been noted (10 days on average for sedentary workers). Conclusion: The main advantages of this technique are simplicity, low cost, reduced postoperative disability and early return to work. It is much too early to say anything concerning recurrence in this series.