Free Rides in Logical Space Diagrams Versus Aristotelian Diagrams

被引：5
|
作者：
Smessaert, Hans [1 ]
Shimojima, Atsushi [2 ]
Demey, Lorenz [3 ]
机构：
[1] Katholieke Univ Leuven, Dept Linguist, Blijde Inkomststr 21, B-3000 Leuven, Belgium
[2] Doshisha Univ, Fac Culture & Informat Sci, 1-3 Tatara Miyakodani, Kyotanabe 6100394, Japan
[3] Katholieke Univ Leuven, Ctr Log & Philosophy Sci, Kardinaal Mercierpl 2, B-3000 Leuven, Belgium
来源：
DIAGRAMMATIC REPRESENTATION AND INFERENCE, DIAGRAMS 2020 | 2020年 / 12169卷
基金：
比利时弗兰德研究基金会;
关键词：
Cognitive potential; Free Ride; Logical Space Diagram; Aristotelian diagram; Translation; Informational/computational equivalence; Degrees of iconicity; INFORMATION;
D O I：
10.1007/978-3-030-54249-8_33
中图分类号：
TP18 [人工智能理论];
学科分类号：
081104 ; 0812 ; 0835 ; 1405 ;
摘要：
In this paper we compare two types of diagrams for the representation of logical relations such as contradiction and contrariety, namely Logical Space diagrams (LSD) and Aristotelian diagrams (AD). The cognitive potential of Free Ride - defined in terms of tracking by consequence (Shimojima 2015) - is shown to hold for LSDs but not for ADs. The latter, however, do exhibit a greater inspection potential defined in terms of tracking by correlation. The translational or informational equivalence between LSDs and ADs is contrasted to their lack of computational equivalence and their different degrees of iconicity.
引用
收藏
页码：419 / 435
页数：17
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Logical and Geometrical Complementarities between Aristotelian Diagrams
    Smessaert, Hans
    Demey, Lorenz
    [J]. DIAGRAMMATIC REPRESENTATION AND INFERENCE, DIAGRAMS 2014, 2014, 8578 : 246 - 260
  • [2] A Database of Aristotelian Diagrams: Empirical Foundations for Logical Geometry
    Demey, Lorenz
    Smessaert, Hans
    [J]. DIAGRAMMATIC REPRESENTATION AND INFERENCE, DIAGRAMS 2022, 2022, 13462 : 123 - 131
  • [3] From Euler Diagrams to Aristotelian Diagrams
    Demey, Lorenz
    Smessaert, Hans
    [J]. DIAGRAMMATIC REPRESENTATION AND INFERENCE, DIAGRAMS 2022, 2022, 13462 : 279 - 295
  • [4] Logical and Geometrical Distance in Polyhedral Aristotelian Diagrams in Knowledge Representation
    Demey, Lorenz
    Smessaert, Hans
    [J]. SYMMETRY-BASEL, 2017, 9 (10): : 204
  • [5] Morphisms Between Aristotelian Diagrams
    De Klerck, Alexander
    Vignero, Leander
    Demey, Lorenz
    [J]. LOGICA UNIVERSALIS, 2024, 18 (1-2) : 49 - 83
  • [6] Generalizing Aristotelian Relations and Diagrams
    Frijters, Stef
    [J]. DIAGRAMMATIC REPRESENTATION AND INFERENCE, DIAGRAMS 2022, 2022, 13462 : 329 - 337
  • [7] Aspect Shifting in Aristotelian Diagrams
    Smessaert, Hans
    Demey, Lorenz
    [J]. DIAGRAMMATIC REPRESENTATION AND INFERENCE, DIAGRAMS 2022, 2022, 13462 : 226 - 234
  • [8] The Aristotelian Mechanics: Text and Diagrams
    De Groot, Jean
    [J]. ISIS, 2018, 109 (01) : 164 - 165
  • [9] The Modal Logic of Aristotelian Diagrams
    Frijters, Stef
    Demey, Lorenz
    [J]. AXIOMS, 2023, 12 (05)
  • [10] Combining and Relating Aristotelian Diagrams
    Vignero, Leander
    [J]. DIAGRAMMATIC REPRESENTATION AND INFERENCE, DIAGRAMS 2021, 2021, 12909 : 221 - 228
12345