Aristotle on Substance as Primary in Time

被引:2
|
作者
Sattler, Wolfgang [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Fed Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil
来源
关键词
Aristotle; Metaphysics; substance; time; primacy/priority; SEPARATION;
D O I
10.1163/15685284-12341049
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
In a notoriously obscure passage in Metaphysics 7.1 Aristotle claims that substance is primary in time. The only concrete literal interpretation suggested so far of this controversial claim is in terms of existing before and after in time. I argue that this interpretation faces serious problems. I then present a novel literal interpretation, in terms of being an appropriate subject of temporal predications, that is immune to these problems and strongly supported by philosophical and contextual considerations.
引用
收藏
页码:274 / 293
页数:20
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Unity and primary substance for Aristotle
    Deavel, CJ
    PHILOSOPHY AND INTERCULTURAL UNDERSTANDING, 2004, 77 : 159 - 172
  • [2] SUBSTANCE AND THE PRIMARY SENSE OF BEING IN ARISTOTLE
    Brook, Angus
    REVIEW OF METAPHYSICS, 2015, 68 (03): : 521 - 544
  • [3] ORIGIN OF ARISTOTLE CONCEPT OF PRIMARY SUBSTANCE IN PLATO TIMAEUS
    DRISCOLL, JA
    JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 1978, 75 (10): : 576 - 576
  • [4] SUBSTANCE AND FORM IN ARISTOTLE .1. SUBSTANCE AND FORM IN ARISTOTLE
    SELLARS, W
    JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 1957, 54 (22): : 688 - 699
  • [5] Plotinus' criticism of Aristotle's doctrine of primary substance and its background
    Kalligas, Paul
    ARISTOTLE AND HIS COMMENTATORS: STUDIES IN MEMORY OF PARASKEVI KOTZIA, 2019, 7 : 83 - 94
  • [6] VIRTUE AND SUBSTANCE IN ARISTOTLE
    Baciu, Claudiu
    REVUE ROUMAINE DE PHILOSOPHIE, 2021, 65 (02): : 371 - 379
  • [7] ARISTOTLE ON THE UNITY OF SUBSTANCE
    LEWIS, FA
    PACIFIC PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY, 1995, 76 (3-4): : 222 - 265
  • [8] Substance and Life in Aristotle
    Shields, Christopher
    APEIRON-A JOURNAL FOR ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY AND SCIENCE, 2008, 41 (03): : 129 - 151
  • [9] KNOWLEDGE OF SUBSTANCE IN ARISTOTLE
    HEINAMAN, R
    JOURNAL OF HELLENIC STUDIES, 1981, 101 : 63 - 77
  • [10] Aristotle on Secondary Substance
    Mahlan, John Robert
    APEIRON-A JOURNAL FOR ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY AND SCIENCE, 2019, 52 (02): : 167 - 197