Characterization of a nontumorigenic human breast epithelial cell line stably transfected with the human estrogen receptor (ER) cDNA

Estrogens play an important role in breast cancer and the effect of estrogen on growth of breast cancer cells has been extensively studied. However, only little information is available about the response of normal breast epithelial cells to estrogen, mainly due to the difficulties in establishing estrogen receptor (ER)-positive human breast epithelial cells ill culture. We have stably transfected the human estrogen receptor (hER) wt cDNA into the ER-negative, spontaneously immortalized human breast epithelial cell Line, HMT-3522S1, in order to develop a model for studying the effect of estrogen on nonmalignant human breast epithelial cells. Characterization of the transfected clone F9 confirmed incorporation of the estrogen receptor gene in the genome, expression of hER mRNA and hER protein. However, proliferation of F9 cells was inhibited by both estradiol (E(2)) and tamoxifen? whereas the pure antiestrogen ICI 182,780 had no effect on cell proliferation. This seems paradoxical since E(2) stimulated the expression of the endogenous genes, TGF-alpha, cathepsin D, and alpha(1)-antitrypsin. In breast cancer cell lines, high expression of these genes is correlated to estrogen-stimulated cell proliferation. The spontaneously immortalized HMT-3522S1 cells transfected with wt ER cDNA behave similarly to cell lines from nonmalignant breast tissue immortalized by carcinogens and transfected with mutated ER cDNA as described by others. The discrepancy between growth inhibition and induction of positive growth factors by E(2) indicates that either ER-positive nonmalignant breast epithelial cells are growth-inhibited by E? in contrast to malignant cells or that introduction of the ER into ER-negative cells is not sufficient for restoring 'normal' estrogen responsiveness.