Differential Effects of Retinoids and Inhibitors of ERK and p38 Signaling on Adipogenic and Myogenic Differentiation of P19 Stem Cells

All-trans-retinoic acid (atRA) is an essential signaling molecule in embryonic development. It regulates cell differentiation by activating nuclear retinoic acid receptors (RAR) and retinoid-X receptors (RXR), which both control gene expression. In addition, atRA could act in the cytoplasm by modulating the activity of mitogen-activated protein kinases (MAPK) ERK and p38, which also have a role in cell differentiation. AtRA can induce the differentiation of P19 embryonic carcinoma stem cells into adipocytes, cardiomyocytes, and skeletal muscle cells, concurrently, in the same culture. We postulated that combinations of atRA, atRA analogs exhibiting selectivity for RAR or RXR, and inhibitors of ERK and p38 signaling (ERKi and p38i) could be used to favor one mesodermal fate over the others in the P19 model. In a first series of experiments, we replaced atRA by an agonist of RXR (LG100268) or RAR (TTNPB) to preferentially stimulate one group of receptors over the other. LG100268 was as adipogenic and myogenic as atRA, whereas TTNPB strongly induced adipogenesis, but not myogenesis. ERKi enhanced the myogenic action of atRA, and p38i increased both adipogenesis and myogenesis. In a second series of experiments, we combined atRA with an RAR or RXR antagonist (RARatg or RXRatg) to preferentially deactivate each receptor group in turn. The combinations atRA + RXRatg and atRA + RARatg, including or not ERKi, had similar mesodermal actions as atRA. In contrast, there was no myogenesis with atRA + RXRatg + p38i treatment, and there were no myogenesis and no adipogenesis with the atRA + RARatg + p38i combination. Overall, the results indicate that p38 has a role in mesodermal differentiation that depends on the retinoid context. Indeed, p38 in conjunction with RXR is important in myogenesis, and p38 and RAR in adipogenesis. Under the conditions tested, it was possible to stimulate adipogenesis with a block on myogenesis, whereas increased myogenesis was accompanied by adipogenesis.