How scientists advising the European Commission on research priorities view climate engineering proposals

被引:10
|
作者
Himmelsbach, Raffael [1 ]
机构
[1] Linkoping Univ, Inst Themat Studies Environm Change, Linkoping, Sweden
基金
瑞典研究理事会;
关键词
climate engineering; scientific governance; European research policy; socio-technical imaginaries; SOLAR-RADIATION MANAGEMENT; POLICY; MITIGATION; DISCOURSES; RESPONSES; POLITICS; FUTURE; ISSUES;
D O I
10.1093/scipol/scx053
中图分类号
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号
08 ; 0830 ;
摘要
This study contributes to a growing body of research that studies how different societal actors view climate engineering (CE) in an effort to 'open up' received framings and make them amenable to deliberations. CE is an umbrella term for different proposals of how to counteract global warming with technological means, some of which have sparked controversy. Drawing on fifteen interviews, the study explores how scientists who advise the European Commission on research funding priorities regarding climate change and sustainability view CE. They considered CE as treating the symptoms rather than the causes of climate change, as interfering in complex and unpredictable natural systems, and as engendering questions of distributive justice. They also stressed the complexity of governing climate change and expressed support for basic CE research. The concluding discussion dwells on the implications of foresight, the division of labor in research governance, and the challenge of poverty for governing technologies in the service of climate action.
引用
收藏
页码:124 / 133
页数:10
相关论文
共 34 条
  • [1] Ethical evaluation of research proposals by ethics panels advising the European Commission
    Kolar, R
    ATLA-ALTERNATIVES TO LABORATORY ANIMALS, 2004, 32 : 429 - 439
  • [2] EUROPEAN COMMISSION TABLES NEW PROPOSALS ON GENOME RESEARCH
    MACKENZIE, D
    NEW SCIENTIST, 1989, 124 (1692) : 24 - 24
  • [3] Priorities for research on environment, climate and health, a European perspective
    Elina Drakvik
    Manolis Kogevinas
    Åke Bergman
    Anais Devouge
    Robert Barouki
    Environmental Health, 21
  • [4] HOW ENGINEERING EDUCATORS VIEW RESEARCH
    GARRETT, PH
    THOMSON, WJ
    BARNES, FS
    CHERRY, LB
    FORESTI, R
    HALL, JL
    PRIMROSE, RA
    BROWN, WS
    REYNOLDS, DD
    CLARKE, EN
    WHITMORE, HE
    ENGINEERING EDUCATION, 1973, 63 (04): : 273 - 275
  • [5] Climate research priorities for policy-makers, practitioners, and scientists in Georgia, USA
    Murray A. Rudd
    Althea F. P. Moore
    Daniel Rochberg
    Lisa Bianchi-Fossati
    Marilyn A. Brown
    David D’Onofrio
    Carrie A. Furman
    Jairo Garcia
    Ben Jordan
    Jennifer Kline
    L. Mark Risse
    Patricia L. Yager
    Jessica Abbinett
    Merryl Alber
    Jesse E. Bell
    Cyrus Bhedwar
    Kim M. Cobb
    Juliet Cohen
    Matt Cox
    Myriam Dormer
    Nyasha Dunkley
    Heather Farley
    Jill Gambill
    Mindy Goldstein
    Garry Harris
    Melissa Hopkinson
    Jean-Ann James
    Susan Kidd
    Pam Knox
    Yang Liu
    Daniel C. Matisoff
    Michael D. Meyer
    Jamie D. Mitchem
    Katherine Moore
    Aspen J. Ono
    Jon Philipsborn
    Kerrie M. Sendall
    Fatemeh Shafiei
    Marshall Shepherd
    Julia Teebken
    Ashby N. Worley
    Environmental Management, 2018, 62 : 190 - 209
  • [6] Climate research priorities for policy-makers, practitioners, and scientists in Georgia, USA
    Rudd, Murray A.
    Moore, Althea F. P.
    Rochberg, Daniel
    Bianchi-Fossati, Lisa
    Brown, Marilyn A.
    D'Onofrio, David
    Furman, Carrie A.
    Garcia, Jairo
    Jordan, Ben
    Kline, Jennifer
    Risse, L. Mark
    Yager, Patricia L.
    Abbinett, Jessica
    Alber, Merryl
    Bell, Jesse E.
    Bhedwar, Cyrus
    Cobb, Kim M.
    Cohen, Juliet
    Cox, Matt
    Dormer, Myriam
    Dunkley, Nyasha
    Farley, Heather
    Gambill, Jill
    Goldstein, Mindy
    Harris, Garry
    Hopkinson, Melissa
    James, Jean-Ann
    Kidd, Susan
    Knox, Pam
    Liu, Yang
    Matisoff, Daniel C.
    Meyer, Michael D.
    Mitchem, Jamie D.
    Moore, Katherine
    Ono, Aspen J.
    Philipsborn, Jon
    Sendall, Kerrie M.
    Shafiei, Fatemeh
    Shepherd, Marshall
    Teebken, Julia
    Worley, Ashby N.
    ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT, 2018, 62 (02) : 190 - 209
  • [7] Priorities for research on environment, climate and health, a European perspective COMMENT
    Drakvik, Elina
    Kogevinas, Manolis
    Bergman, Ake
    Devouge, Anais
    Barouki, Robert
    ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH, 2022, 21 (01)
  • [9] How the European Commission Policy Supports Research and Development in Photovoltaics
    Rzadkowska, A.
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE ISES EUROSUN 2020 CONFERENCE - 13TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON SOLAR ENERGY FOR BUILDINGS AND INDUSTRY, 2020, : 872 - 879
  • [10] Key impacts of climate engineering on biodiversity and ecosystems, with priorities for future research
    McCormack, Caitlin G.
    Born, Wanda
    Irvine, Peter J.
    Achterberg, Eric P.
    Amano, Tatsuya
    Ardron, Jeff
    Foster, Pru N.
    Gattuso, Jean-Pierre
    Hawkins, Stephen J.
    Hendy, Erica
    Kissling, W. Daniel
    Lluch-Cota, Salvador E.
    Murphy, Eugene J.
    Ostle, Nick
    Owens, Nicholas J. P.
    Perry, R. Ian
    Poertner, Hans O.
    Scholes, Robert J.
    Schurr, Frank M.
    Schweiger, Oliver
    Settele, Josef
    Smith, Rebecca K.
    Smith, Sarah
    Thompson, Jill
    Tittensor, Derek P.
    van Kleunen, Mark
    Vivian, Chris
    Vohland, Katrin
    Warren, Rachel
    Watkinson, Andrew R.
    Widdicombe, Steve
    Williamson, Phillip
    Woods, Emma
    Blackstock, Jason J.
    Sutherland, William J.
    JOURNAL OF INTEGRATIVE ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES, 2016, 13 (2-4) : 103 - 128