"How Many Silences Are There?" Men's Experience of Victimization in Intimate Partner Relationships

被引:34
|
作者
Brooks, Carolyn [1 ]
Martin, Stephanie [2 ]
Broda, Lisa [3 ]
Poudrier, Jennifer [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Saskatchewan, Sociol, Saskatoon, SK, Canada
[2] Univ Saskatchewan, Dept Educ Psychol & Special Educ, Saskatoon, SK, Canada
[3] Univ Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, SK, Canada
关键词
intimate partner violence; hegemonic masculinities; qualitative research; male victimization; women's violence; HETEROSEXUAL PARTNERS; HEGEMONIC MASCULINITY; SEX-DIFFERENCES; VIOLENCE; CHALLENGES; VICTIMS; STRESS; ABUSE; WOMEN; POWER;
D O I
10.1177/0886260517719905
中图分类号
DF [法律]; D9 [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
There is a substantive body of research focusing on women's experiences of intimate partner violence (IPV), but a lack of qualitative studies focusing on men's experiences asvictimsof IPV. This article addresses this gap in the literature by paying particular attention to hegemonic masculinities and men's perceptions of IPV. Men (N= 9) participated in in-depth interviews. Interview data were rigorously subjected to thematic analysis, which revealed five key themes in the men's narratives: fear of IPV, maintaining power and control, victimization as a forbidden narrative, critical understanding of IPV, and breaking the silence. Although the men share similar stories of victimization as women, the way this is influenced by their gendered histories is different. While some men reveal a willingness to disclose their victimization and share similar fear to women victims, others reframe their victim status in a way that sustains their own power and control. The men also draw attention to the contextual realities that frame abuse, including histories of violence against the women who used violence and the realities of communities suffering intergenerational affects of colonized histories. The findings reinforce the importance of in-depth qualitative work toward revealing the context of violence, understanding the impact of fear, victimization, and power/control on men's mental health as well as the outcome of legal and support services and lack thereof. A critical discussion regarding the gendered context of violence, power within relationships, and addressing men's need for support without redefining victimization or taking away from policies and support for women's ongoing victimization concludes the work.
引用
收藏
页码:5390 / 5413
页数:24
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Masculinities and men's emotions in and after intimate partner relationships
    Oliffe, John L.
    Broom, Alex
    Ridge, Damien
    Kelly, Mary T.
    Montaner, Gabriela Gonzalez
    Seidler, Zac E.
    Rice, Simon M.
    [J]. SOCIOLOGY OF HEALTH & ILLNESS, 2023, 45 (02) : 366 - 385
  • [2] Men's differential identification with female-perpetrated intimate partner victimization
    Cocking, Cydney A. L. M.
    Oswald, Flora
    Pedersen, Cory L.
    [J]. PSYCHOLOGY & SEXUALITY, 2024,
  • [3] Feminism, Status Inconsistency, and Women's Intimate Partner Victimization in Heterosexual Relationships
    Franklin, Cortney A.
    Menaker, Tasha A.
    [J]. VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN, 2014, 20 (07) : 825 - 845
  • [4] Picture this: Men building intimate partner relationships
    Oliffe, John L.
    Gao, Nina
    Kelly, Mary T.
    Shim, Andrea
    Yap, Celene Y. L.
    Sharp, Paul
    Mckenzie, Sarah
    [J]. HEALTH EDUCATION JOURNAL, 2024,
  • [5] Masculinity and mental illness in and after men's intimate partner relationships
    Oliffe, John L.
    Kelly, Mary T.
    Montaner, Gabriela Gonzalez
    Seidler, Zac E.
    Ogrodniczuk, John S.
    Rice, Simon M.
    [J]. SSM-QUALITATIVE RESEARCH IN HEALTH, 2022, 2
  • [6] Contextualizing Cisgender Women's Histories of Intimate Partner Violence Victimization With Men and Women
    Mccauley, Heather L.
    Reid, Taylor A.
    Anderson, RaeAnn E.
    Ast, Roxanna
    Zelazny, Sarah
    Miller, Elizabeth
    [J]. VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN, 2023, 29 (15-16) : 3244 - 3262
  • [7] Young Women's Intimate Partner Violence Victimization Patterns Across Multiple Relationships
    Kennedy, Angie C.
    Bybee, Deborah
    McCauley, Heather L.
    Prock, Kristen A.
    [J]. PSYCHOLOGY OF WOMEN QUARTERLY, 2018, 42 (04) : 430 - 444
  • [8] Characteristics of Intimate Partner Violence Victimization Experienced by a Sample of Portuguese Men
    Machado, Andreia
    Hines, Denise
    Matos, Marlene
    [J]. VIOLENCE AND VICTIMS, 2018, 33 (01) : 157 - 175
  • [9] Third-Party Perceptions of Intimate Partner Violence Victimization in Men
    Thomas, Paul A.
    Hart, Kathleen J.
    [J]. PSYCHOLOGY OF MEN & MASCULINITIES, 2023, 24 (01): : 34 - 46
  • [10] Severity of Victimization and Formal Help Seeking Among Men Who Experienced Intimate Partner Violence in Their Ongoing Relationships
    Lysova, Alexandra
    Dim, Eugene E.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF INTERPERSONAL VIOLENCE, 2022, 37 (3-4) : 1404 - 1429