The Dark Side of Light Traps

被引:52
|
作者
McDermott, Emily G. [1 ]
Mullens, Bradley A. [2 ]
机构
[1] Walter Reed Army Inst Res, Entomol Branch, Vector & Parasite Biol, Silver Spring, MD 20910 USA
[2] Univ Calif Riverside, Dept Entomol, Riverside, CA 92521 USA
关键词
light trap; surveillance; vector; trapping; CULICOIDES-VARIIPENNIS DIPTERA; PHLEBOTOMINE SAND FLIES; NILE-VIRUS SURVEILLANCE; AEDES-AEGYPTI DIPTERA; BITING MIDGES DIPTERA; NORTH CENTRAL FLORIDA; CARBON-DIOXIDE; FLIGHT ACTIVITY; BG-SENTINEL; NORTHEASTERN COLORADO;
D O I
10.1093/jme/tjx207
中图分类号
Q96 [昆虫学];
学科分类号
摘要
Light-baited suction traps are one of the most widely used tools for vector surveillance. Their popularity stems from ease of use even in remote locations, range and abundance of species caught, and low cost. The availability of smaller, portable models, like the CDC miniature light trap, have further increased their ubiquity in entomological field studies. However, when researchers have looked, light trap collections are usually biased in ways that may affect data interpretation for epidemiological studies. If used alone, light traps may fail to collect important or infected vectors, and light traps are inefficient or ineffective when competing ambient light is present. In this article, we discuss these biases and limitations in terms of their effect on collection efficiency, population data, and pathogen detection. While light trap data certainly have a purpose, an over-reliance on light trapping risks drawing false conclusions about vector populations and vector-borne disease epidemiology. These concerns are especially troubling when light trap data are used to inform policy decisions meant to protect human and animal health. Particularly when a species' response to light is unknown or poorly characterized, light traps should be used in conjunction with supplemental sampling methods. Researchers conducting vector surveillance field studies should carefully consider their study design and objectives when deciding on a trapping method or methods, and specifically endeavor to understand the limitations of their data. Only then can researchers take advantage of the best attributes of light traps while avoiding their dark side.
引用
下载
收藏
页码:251 / 261
页数:11
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] THE DARK SIDE OF LIGHT
    Irwin, Aisling
    NATURE, 2018, 553 (7688) : 268 - +
  • [2] A light and a dark side
    Elbert, T
    Heim, S
    NATURE, 2001, 411 (6834) : 139 - 139
  • [3] A light and a dark side
    Thomas Elbert
    Sabine Heim
    Nature, 2001, 411 : 139 - 139
  • [4] Dark side of the light
    Sullivan, Edward
    EDN, 2009, 54 (15) : 58 - 58
  • [5] THE DARK SIDE OF LIGHT
    Schuler, Timothy A.
    LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE, 2020, 110 (12) : 66 - 76
  • [6] Neutrophil extracellular traps - the dark side of neutrophils
    Sorensen, Ole E.
    Borregaard, Niels
    JOURNAL OF CLINICAL INVESTIGATION, 2016, 126 (05): : 1612 - 1620
  • [7] Shining a light on the dark side
    Furnham, Adrian
    PSYCHOLOGIST, 2019, 32 : 56 - 59
  • [8] Shining a Light on the Dark Side
    Ray, Linda
    ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE, 2016, 164 (01) : 68 - +
  • [9] The light and dark side of TARP
    Farruggio, Christian
    Michalak, Tobias C.
    Uhde, Andre
    JOURNAL OF BANKING & FINANCE, 2013, 37 (07) : 2586 - 2604
  • [10] The light side of dark matter
    Bernard J. Carr
    Nature Astronomy, 2019, 3 : 485 - 486