It Costs a Lot to Look This Cheap: Preference for Low-Quality Graphic Design

Some 1,000 surveys were conducted on Amazon's MTurk, asking respondents to rate a high- and low-quality visual design, in this case a billboard ad. While most respondents preferred the high-quality ad, over a third opted for the low-quality design. Respondents who showed a preference for the low-quality design liked it for its "static" qualities, in that it was common, typical, average, and standard. Those who preferred the high-quality design liked it for its "dynamic" qualities, such that it was innovative, fascinating, novel, creative, and rich in elements. Older participants show a significant preference for the low-quality design. Implications of these findings for different types of visual communication are discussed.