The political importance of analogical argument

被引:8
|
作者
Aronovitch, H
机构
关键词
D O I
10.1111/1467-9248.00071
中图分类号
D0 [政治学、政治理论];
学科分类号
0302 ; 030201 ;
摘要
Is there a form of reasoning somehow specially suited to political philosophy and political life? I contend that for a variety of reasons analogical argument is eminently apt for politics. Although the significance of analogical reasoning for law has been largely recognized, its similar suitability for morality and politics has mostly been ignored, though insights from Hampshire and others point the way. An eventual implication of my argument is that an analogically developed liberal tradition provides rational, non-relativist 'foundations' for normative claims, as firm as are feasible and necessary. This larger question about the roots of political and moral principles is commented upon throughout, but the main purpose is to establish the nature and legitimacy of analogical reasoning in political argument.
引用
收藏
页码:78 / 92
页数:15
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] ANALOGICAL ARGUMENT IN 'INFINITO' OF BRUNO
    BREINER, LA
    [J]. MLN-MODERN LANGUAGE NOTES, 1978, 93 (01): : 22 - 35
  • [2] Analogical Argument Schemes and Complex Argumentation
    Juthe, Andre
    [J]. INFORMAL LOGIC, 2015, 35 (03): : 378 - 445
  • [3] Analogical and Political Hermeneutics
    Beuchot, Mauricio
    [J]. ANACRONISMO E IRRUPCION, 2012, 2 (03): : 181 - 193
  • [4] ANALOGICAL AND POLITICAL HERMENEUTICS
    Beuchot, Mauricio
    [J]. CUADERNOS DE FILOSOFIA LATINOAMERICANA, 2005, 26 (93): : 35 - 42
  • [5] The role and limits of analogical argument: A reply to Aronovitch
    Lessnoff, M
    [J]. POLITICAL STUDIES, 1997, 45 (01) : 93 - 96
  • [6] ANALOGICAL ARGUMENT FOR KNOWLEDGE OF OTHER MINDS RECONSIDERED
    OLSHEWSKY, TM
    [J]. AMERICAN PHILOSOPHICAL QUARTERLY, 1974, 11 (01) : 63 - 69
  • [7] Argument-Based Logic Programming for Analogical Reasoning
    Racharak, Teeradaj
    Tojo, Satoshi
    Nguyen Duy Hung
    Boonkwan, Prachya
    [J]. NEW FRONTIERS IN ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, 2017, 10247 : 253 - 269
  • [8] Analogical argument, liberalism, and the avoidance of relativism: Reply to Lessnoff
    Aronovitch, H
    [J]. POLITICAL STUDIES, 1997, 45 (01) : 97 - 99
  • [9] XUNZI AND MIMAMSA ON THE SOURCE AND GROUND OF RITUAL: AN ANALOGICAL ARGUMENT
    McLeod, Alexus
    [J]. PHILOSOPHY EAST & WEST, 2018, 68 (03): : 737 - 761
  • [10] This argument is not political
    Pirocanac, D
    [J]. POLLUTION ENGINEERING, 1996, 28 (02) : 7 - 7